Tweet
Originally posted by Dynamite Kid
View Post
-
I have it 2-1 Toney, but I thought the second was a 'swing' round, so 3-0 Toney is reasonable IMO. -
-
-
-
Update Shadows?Comment
-
I'm going into the 10th, and I have Toney 5-4.Originally posted by Dynamite Kid View Post
I have three possible 'swing' rounds though.Comment
-
finished yet Shadows?Comment
-
Just finished watching McCallum-Toney II. This is how I scored it:
1. Toney, 10-9
Toney takes it on his activity and aggression.
2. McCallum, 10-9
This was a close round with both guys having a good stretch. I gave it to McCallum based upon his jab and body work.
3. Toney, 10-9
Toney controlled the round with his jab, and was picking off a lot of shots in the process. McCallum landed one nice combination of note.
4. Toney, 10-9
Not much really happened, a cagey round. McCallum landed a nice flurry, but Toney landed the harder shots during the round, most notably, a good right hand with a minute left (if I remember correctly
).
5. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum controlled the tempo and distance with his jab. Toney landed a nice uppercut and right hand, but was too inactive for me.
6. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum dictated the round again with his jab. He's also slipped and picked off a lot of shots. Toney is too apprehensive and is really only throwing single shots.
7. Toney, 10-9
Close round. There was more fighting on the inside. Toney takes it, as he landed the harder shots.
8. Toney, 10-8
Close round. Point deduction from McCallum; kinda iffy. More fighting on the inside, with Toney doing the better work; landed some nice shots, most notably a left hook.
9. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum simply outworks Toney. To started to land some good, effective body shots.
10. McCallum, 10-9
Close round. Toney landed some nice, hard shots, but again, was fighting in spurts. McCallum was far more active and landed several good combinations to the body.
11. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum looks tired, but still outlanded and outworked Toney.
12. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum controlled the round and scored points. Toney was way too inactive.
114-113 McCallum, 7-5 with the point deduction.
All in all, it was a close and cagey fight that I thought McCallum won simply on outworking Toney, who only fought in spurts. Hell, during the championship rounds, McCallum looked tired but was doing the better work. I was just waiting for Toney to step on the gas.
However, there were a three close rounds IMO, so I think it's reasonable that Toney could've gotten the nod--but no way by scores of 117-11 or 118-110.
EDIT: Sorry for keeping you up all night, seeing as you're across the pond.Last edited by Shadows; 11-09-2009, 10:43 PM.Comment
-
Originally posted by Shadows View PostJust finished watching McCallum-Toney II. This is how I scored it:
1. Toney, 10-9
Toney takes it on his activity and aggression.
2. McCallum, 10-9
This was a close round with both guys having a good stretch. I gave it to McCallum based upon his jab and body work.
3. Toney, 10-9
Toney controlled the round with his jab, and was picking off a lot of shots in the process. McCallum landed one nice combination of note.
4. Toney, 10-9
Not much really happened, a cagey round. McCallum landed a nice flurry, but Toney landed the harder shots during the round, most notably, a good right hand with a minute left (if I remember correctly).
5. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum controlled the tempo and distance with his jab. Toney landed a nice uppercut and right hand, but was too inactive for me.
6. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum dictated the round again with his jab. He's also slipped and picked off a lot of shots. Toney is too apprehensive and is really only throwing single shots.
7. Toney, 10-9
Close round. There was more fighting on the inside. Toney takes it, as he landed the harder shots.
8. Toney, 10-8
Close round. Point deduction from McCallum; kinda iffy. More fighting on the inside, with Toney doing the better work; landed some nice shots, most notably a left hook.
9. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum simply outworks Toney. To started to land some good, effective body shots.
10. McCallum, 10-9
Close round. Toney landed some nice, hard shots, but again, was fighting in spurts. McCallum was far more active and landed several good combinations to the body.
11. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum looks tired, but still outlanded and outworked Toney.
12. McCallum, 10-9
McCallum controlled the round and scored points. Toney was way too inactive.
114-113 McCallum, 7-5 with the point deduction.
All in all, it was a close and cagey fight that I thought McCallum won simply on outworking Toney, who only fought in spurts. Hell, during the championship rounds, McCallum looked tired but was doing the better work. I was just waiting for Toney to step on the gas.
However, there were a three close rounds IMO, so I think it's reasonable that Toney could've gotten the nod--but no way by scores of 117-11 or 118-110.
EDIT: Sorry for keeping you up all night, seeing as you're across the pond.
Pretty much in line with what i had. I just could not give Toney's certain rounds where he was so inactive.
Yeah you mofo keeping me up all night waiting for you scorecard nah i enjoyed watching that fight and being able to get your take on it to, that fight was high class Boxing just like the first.
Comment
-
Would you guys be interested in scoring Castillo vs Mayweather 1?Comment
Comment