Most Inconsistant?

[Willie Pep 229]

Who has been the most inconsistant performer in the fight game over the past 50 years?

James Toney seems the obvious answer but I'm leaning towards Holyfield. Then against there's Mercer.

Any opinions?

[Good ol' Douglas]

Jimmy Young?

Robbed against Ali, beat Foreman and went to a SD with Norton despite having a record of 35-18-3.

[IronDanHamza]

Holyfield inconsistent how? Because he lost to Moorer and was 1-2 with Bowe?

Holyfield cleaned out Cruiserweight, then won the HW title.

Was Ali inconsistent too?

You can’t even compare Holyfield to Toney, Toney lost/drew to journeyman in his prime years multiple times.

[QueensburyRules]

Holyfield inconsistent how? Because he lost to Moorer and was 1-2 with Bowe?

Holyfield cleaned out Cruiserweight, then won the HW title.

Was Ali inconsistent too?

You can’t even compare Holyfield to Toney, Toney lost/drew to journeyman in his prime years multiple times.

- - Ali barely showed up the last few years of his career and started his career along the same way.

Do I have to recite the heavy record of Vander for the umpteenth time?

[markusmod]

Daniel Jacobs?