Post You All-Time Great Lists! (No Trolls)

[The Iron Man]

Ok the gauntlet has been thrown beat this list

Armstrong
Burley
Charles
Duran
Erdei
Fitzsimmons
Greb
Hagler
Ibeabuchi
Jones
Ketchel
Langford
Moore
Norton
Ottke
Pep
Quartey
Robinson
Sanchez
Tiger
Uzcudun
Villa
Wilde
Xiao Wei (well he's undefeated lol) Personally i'd rather go with Galaxy
Young Stribling
Zarate

You think we saw enough of him to really rate him up with these great names!?

[BOLLOCKS]

Because Arguello was a freakin' beast.....unlike Fraud Gayweather who only scores as a p4p trash talking punk.

Poet

Mayweather > Arguello, imo.

[Obama]

That's a new one: I'm usually rather critical of Jones, especially when people start talking about him being the best ever.

Poet

You rated Jones in the top 20, and closer to 10 than 20. I know some HUGE Jones nuthuggers that don't have that kind of audacity. It's down right disgraceful.

[GJC]

He's definately better than Xiao Wei
For a bit of fun I knocked up an ATG list from A to Z, if you have a better I i'll happily alter it. I was a struggle as was E O U and X, I also think there must be a better N than Norton, no disrespect to Ken.
I put up my proper ATG list earlier.

[GJC]

He's definately better than Xiao Wei
For a bit of fun I knocked up an ATG list from A to Z, if you have a better I i'll happily alter it. I was a struggle as was E O U and X, I also think there must be a better N than Norton, no disrespect to Ken.
I put up my proper ATG list earlier.

That was to Iron Man BTW who I imagine must think the alzheimers has finally hit home for me

[Junito-Rulez]

Mayweather > Arguello, imo.

I agree in terms of pure talent, but we judge the P4P rankings on accomplishments and level of competition. Arguello did MUCH more than Floyd and fought guys like Mancini or Pryor, Floyd ducked Cotto in his own words and avoided an 8 million fight with Margarito.

Floyd is definitely a top 25 for me but since Corrales and Castillo, he didn't fight a prime GREAT fighter. If Floyd beats Mosley or another top WW, i would rank him much higher just based on his gifts. It's a shame that such a great fighter avoided the best big men to protect his 0.

Mayweather had it all: talent, speed, technique, smart, composure, heart, mental. The only problem is that he's afraid to lose his number one spot against the big men. His campaign and reign at welterweight were a travesty.

[The Iron Man]

That was to Iron Man BTW who I imagine must think the alzheimers has finally hit home for me

Haha, i didnt even realise it was an A - Z list i just saw Ibeabuchi! i guess i can be forgiven since its.

for I, i could think of

Sultan Ibragimov and Satoshi Iida...so ill give u ike!

[GJC]

I agree in terms of pure talent, but we judge the P4P rankings on accomplishments and level of competition. Arguello did MUCH more than Floyd and fought guys like Mancini or Pryor, Floyd ducked Cotto in his own words and avoided an 8 million fight with Margarito.

Floyd is definitely a top 25 for me but since Corrales and Castillo, he didn't fight a prime GREAT fighter. If Floyd beats Mosley or another top WW, i would rank him much higher just based on his gifts. It's a shame that such a great fighter avoided the best big men to protect his 0.

Mayweather had it all: talent, speed, technique, smart, composure, heart, mental. The only problem is that he's afraid to lose his number one spot against the big men. His campaign and reign at welterweight were a travesty.

Good post, Mayweather may redeem himself by beating Pacman but if he doesn't even fight him that 0 will look a little shallow.

[GJC]

Haha, i didnt even realise it was an A - Z list i just saw Ibeabuchi! i guess i can be forgiven since its.

for I, i could think of

Sultan Ibragimov and Satoshi Iida...so ill give u ike!

Its a work in progress for sure though I like Nunn instead of Norton for N now. OK your mission is to upgrade E O U and X.

[GJC]

You rated Jones in the top 20, and closer to 10 than 20. I know some HUGE Jones nuthuggers that don't have that kind of audacity. It's down right disgraceful.

Lists are personal things, I agree that Poet has rated Zarate higher than I would and a couple of others such as Perez and Canto.
But I'm sure him and others wouldn't agree with my list
I don't like RJJ but it is hard to keep him out of a top 20 pfp list surely, I know I tried
Arguello has got to make any top 20 IMO
You going to post yours Obama, not for me to criticise but i'd be interested for sure.