Joe Louis vs any great heavyweight

[GJC]

Of cource you don't see it because you're blind to every fact that you don't like to hear.

Hold up the mirror on that one

I didn't say Louis wouldn't beat "anybody".
He'd simply lose to most of the ATG's based on what I've seen from his fights.

ok who would he beat in your opinion.

I don't have a personal dislike for Louis himself

Obviously not you have certainly made that abundantly clear.

Like I said before, take off your so called Marciano fan mask and bend over in the Louis crowd where you belong.

Not so called, if you care to read old posts of mine or I am sure other posters will agree that I am firmly a Marciano fan. Just not a blindly slavish one which ironically is an accusation you level at all Louis fans who make even the most innocuous comments as to his strengths.

[Miburo]

Question: does anyone here see Walcott or Charles beating Louis in his prime?

[Slimey Limey]

Question: does anyone here see Walcott or Charles beating Louis in his prime?

Walcott already did.


Charles is another great slick boxer so yes he would certainly beat a prime Louis.

[mickey malone]

Question: does anyone here see Walcott or Charles beating Louis in his prime?

No.. I think Louis beats both....

[Slimey Limey]

Hold up the mirror on that one


ok who would he beat in your opinion.



Obviously not you have certainly made that abundantly clear.



Not so called, if you care to read old posts of mine or I am sure other posters will agree that I am firmly a Marciano fan. Just not a blindly slavish one which ironically is an accusation you level at all Louis fans who make even the most innocuous comments as to his strengths.

Ali, Lewis, Foreman, Liston, Tyson, Holmes would beat him with ease. Frazier and Marciano would catch up with him. He'd fare the worst. It's up to you all who he would beat, or actually I wouldn't ask anyone in this section.

[GJC]

And you just added Walcott and Charles to that list, so who if anyone in your opinion would Louis beat? C'mon must be half a dozen names you could mention through gritted teeth?

[TheGreatA]

And you just added Walcott and Charles to that list, so who if anyone in your opinion would Louis beat? C'mon must be half a dozen names you could mention through gritted teeth?

Sugar Ray Robinson.

Actually it would probably end in a double TKO, with both men quitting.

[fight_professor]

In my opinion:

Ali, Holmes, Foreman, Tyson, Bowe all beat him easily. Yes Bowe too. Too big, too smart a fighter. Beautiful inside work, hand a good jab.

And Lewis if he didnt get clocked.

[Slimey Limey]

And you just added Walcott and Charles to that list, so who if anyone in your opinion would Louis beat? C'mon must be half a dozen names you could mention through gritted teeth?

I'll let you dwell in your own misery mate. I'm not going to give you the satisfaction of me giving Louis loads of phraise. Like I said, if you think Louis beats most greats you should give good arguments without ignoring his faults. Why won't you answer your own question?

[GJC]

I'll let you dwell in your own misery mate. I'm not going to give you the satisfaction of me giving Louis loads of phraise. Like I said, if you think Louis beats most greats you should give good arguments without ignoring his faults. Why won't you answer your own question?

Because I think it would be good therapy for you to.
You think naming 6 HW champions that Louis would beat is giving "Louis loads of phraise"?
The fact that you won't speaks volumes, I will be dwelling in my own amusement not misery.
My opinion on who Louis beats and who he doesn't are on posts somewhere, i'll not repost them as I don't want your computer monitor to get too much spittle as you reply.