I'm just curious to see how you all view the current state of our sport.
Are we still in a transition period? A year after Floyd retired, we have a situation where the guys who are being touted as the best are either dragging smaller guys up, or are fighting guys who have no chance of winning, or both in some cases. We also a vacuum in the WW division which was dominated for years by Mayweather, which seemingly doesn't want to be filled or plugged, we've got Fury and Wlad going nowhere, etc.
On the flip side, we have Kov vs Ward coming up and Manny coming out of "retirement".
After the Floyd and Manny period (I'm reluctant to call it an era) of domination, are more years like 2016 all we have to look forward to now, or do you all foresee improvement, or further degradation of the sport. Also, if you feel things are going down, how would you turn things around?
Discuss below. Looking for a mature discussion of views and opinions. Fanboy/hater inspired vitriol is not needed.
Boxing is in a dismal state because of Mayweather
he single handily destroyed the sport by becoming the biggest cash cow in the sport
by doing it through ducking and cherrypicking, denying us the matches we wanted to see when they mattered and giving us overpriced PPV in snoozefests against tailor made no hopers instead
now every fighter with a name wants the most $$$$ with the least amount of effort ans sacrifice. everybody wants to be paid millions for fighting bums
Floyd's actions also provoked the networks war, and the GB-Top Rank feud, that are still damaging the sport even more. and he started the whole hypocritic antidoping circus
No man has ever done as much damage to the sport as Floyd
Floyd. The man who killed boxing
How would you rescue or rebuild boxing once rock bottom has been hit?
Personally, I would streamline the number belts, and create situations in which the top boxers are more or less forced into action. Create a tournament/league of sorts for every weight class, have the contenders fight, gain "points", fight the champ at the end. Perhaps two or "leagues" per weight class/governing body, and upon the conclusion of the "leagues", there is a... decider in which the champs fight each other. IBO v IBF, WBA v WBO in semis, then the winners of those fight each other in a final.
That way, there is constant interest, because we have people keeping score, we have top rated contenders fighting each other with some semblance of regularity to climb up the standings/ratings and become champs, etc.
Might be a logistical nightmare, but it would force the best to fight each other, and we wouldn't be forced to have champs fighting in made up weight classes and the like.
As crazy as it sound and most boxing fans wont like but I do think they have to TAKE From the UFC and YES 1 Belt in each Division is a great place to start. It is too many LEECHES in boxing and the LEECHES have sucked boxing DRY. So 1 Belt each Division is needed, always been a fan of the WBC Belt, the rest never really cared about them and I still don't. If Boxing is never going to come under 1 Governing Body then all promoters need to Unify and start working together!
Also VIDEO GAMES, it is hard to reach a younger Demographic when you have NO Boxing Videos Games that features Today's Fighters. I don't know a Sport that doesn't have a successful video game to be honest beside BOXING! Yet they wonder why they don't reach that younger Demographic :dunno:
The state of boxing is pretty dismal. In the US the top guys don't fight each other and they don't fight enough.
I'd be curious to know if it's the same in other countries like Germany and Russia.
I've watched British boxers like Smith and Brook and they seem to be handled like US fighters. That is, fatten up on the cans. avoid any threat, protect the 0 and land the mega fight that puts you on EZ street
If I was Supreme Commander, I'd disband the alphabets, have one governing body, one title for each division and a unified ranking system based on clear rules. Finally I'd create a retirement system for boxers using a % of the promoter's profits.
I don't see that happening in this century but hey maybe The Donald...?:)
don't forget about the sh1tty over priced ppvs like cuntnelo vs smith and fights being over marinated.hell you can make a top 100 problems in boxing.
Yeah plus boxers getting high paydays off fighting #20 fighters
Said last year that the retirement of may and pac will send boxing into a lul. Here we are. 1 star with many still building.
Can you imagine the crap some of tge old ATG would have got if social media existed.
1 umbrella
Yes. I wish Pacman stayed gone. Bradley is a solid scalp for any of the top guys. But top rank still seems to want to keep his fights in house. Plus Bradley may still be able to beat a couple of his fellow ww contemporaries.
I second both those statements.
On a different note, that girl in the Adidas kit is BAD. Who is she?
Not enough personality in the sport.
Too many boxers that wanna be Mayweather
Fear of losing
Fear of being challenged
Al Haymon
PBC
Showtime
No tournaments
Problems in Boxingdon't forget about the sh1tty over priced ppvs like cuntnelo vs smith and fights being over marinated.hell you can make a top 100 problems in boxing.
Point taken. So do you think he should just f*ck off and leave the young lions to fight amongst themselves?
Also, where do you think Tim Bradley fits in to all this? Elite, or high class gate keeper?
Yes. I wish Pacman stayed gone. Bradley is a solid scalp for any of the top guys. But top rank still seems to want to keep his fights in house. Plus Bradley may still be able to beat a couple of his fellow ww contemporaries.
Not enough personality in the sport.
Too many boxers that wanna be Mayweather
Fear of losing
Fear of being challenged
Al Haymon
PBC
Showtime
No tournaments
Problems in Boxing
Guys fighting like Fury or Mayweather are a big problem.
I understand boxing mavens will appreciate Floyd, and for a reason, but such fighters will not be able to generate money for boxing.
Many ppl saw the 'fight of the century' only to be BORED TO DEATH. Sure you can blame tham for not having a refined tastes, but they'll just shrug their shoulders, "f**k that, I'm never watching boxing again". If we don't want to see boxing to give way to MMA and stuff over the next couple of decades, we need to make boxing exciting to an average Joe, not just to a select group of experts.
Can you name a recognizable welterweight who doesn't want to fight Pacman?? That's a scalp One Time would love to own. The thing is Pacman chooses who he fights, not the other way around. None of those top guys can force Pacman to fight them. Which further illustrates what I've said before. It's Floyd/Pacman and canelo's fault to begin with.
Point taken. So do you think he should just f*ck off and leave the young lions to fight amongst themselves?
Also, where do you think Tim Bradley fits in to all this? Elite, or high class gate keeper?
I think the vacuum is there, because there's no ONE WW vying for top spot. I thought that after Floyd retired, WWs would be falling over themselves to take the vacant number one spot. I mean, if you look at it, there isn't a clear gap between any of the current top guys, and with an ageing Pac still around, HE'S who they should be gunning for as well as each other. But instead, all we've gotten is Thurman v Porter - a fight that had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. Problem is, that's the ONLY top fight we've gotten, and Ward v Kov will be the second.
I do agree with the point about guys abolishing this whole concept of fighting pie makers on PPV. I mean, no disrespect, but Beefy looked like he supplemented his regular income of making furniture with boxing. People were charged $70 for such a garbage fight.
There are so much competitive fights that can be made, but Canelo, a supposed P4P boxer is content with fighting no hopers.
Can you name a recognizable welterweight who doesn't want to fight Pacman?? That's a scalp One Time would love to own. The thing is Pacman chooses who he fights, not the other way around. None of those top guys can force Pacman to fight them. Which further illustrates what I've said before. It's Floyd/Pacman and canelo's fault to begin with.
Funny enough, it all started with Floyd and perfected by Pacman. That's how we're reached to this point. But there isn't a vacuum at ww. There are some fine fine ww's right now. We had Porter/One time this year. That was an excellent scrap. There's that young kat knocking heads. All we need is for Garcia to find his balls again. There's a lot of potential there, minus the afore mentioned Pacman still hanging around fighting c class fighters.
But all that needs to be said is Ward/Kova is going down. That's one of the most important fights in quite some time. Then the possibility of GGG/DJ. Another meaningful fight.
If the boxing fans would purge themselves of the infatuation with Floyd/Pacman's overrated ppv runs of fighting guys they know they could beat, (past down to canelo), and demand quality ppv's, if there are going to be ppv's, like Ward/Kova, we could get this ship righted.
Some people have canelo as a top 5 pfp fighter. That seems crazy, because he's not the best at 160, hell, is he even the best at 154?? Lets keep it real. Most people didn't think he beat Lara and who's actually convinced he beats the Charlo bwoys and the BooBoo?
I think the vacuum is there, because there's no ONE WW vying for top spot. I thought that after Floyd retired, WWs would be falling over themselves to take the vacant number one spot. I mean, if you look at it, there isn't a clear gap between any of the current top guys, and with an ageing Pac still around, HE'S who they should be gunning for as well as each other. But instead, all we've gotten is Thurman v Porter - a fight that had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. Problem is, that's the ONLY top fight we've gotten, and Ward v Kov will be the second.
I do agree with the point about guys abolishing this whole concept of fighting pie makers on PPV. I mean, no disrespect, but Beefy looked like he supplemented his regular income of making furniture with boxing. People were charged $70 for such a garbage fight.
There are so many competitive fights that can be made, but Canelo, a supposed P4P boxer is content with fighting no hopers.
The sport is like the wild west if that's an accurate way to describe it there is no order to it all we have too many divisions, too many belts and a case of fighters/promoters not willing to negotiate with other promoters.
The problem with boxing is compare it to a UFC fight care and ask yourself these certain things about that fight card
Was the undercard entertaining
Did the undercard have competitive fights
Was the main-event a fight that should have happened
Now here is how it differs the answer most of the time for UFC is a big fat YES to all of those whereas with boxing the first two mainly are answered with no and 50% of the time with the main-event question being yes/no.
Now that is a problem obviously but there are loads of problems with boxing, boxing fans brag about how much more money their athletes get over UFC/MMA athletes but they completely skip the part about their athletes fighting guys they should be every fight so boxers being paid too much is definitely an issue why would a fighter want to fight someone good for a million dollars (which absolutely should be considered good money) when he can fight a bum like Alexander Brand and earn the same money whilst Brand gets $30k?
The fighters NEED to be forced into taking meaningful fights which leads to another problem... too many promotions and whatever way you want to look at it this is just an issue these guys rarely want to deal with each other because either one will make it impossible and maybe an odd one will be willing to negotiate.
UFC might be monopolized but If you ask people which is more entertaining I'm pretty certain UFC will win that vote most of the time too many greedy people in boxing ruining everything it's a great sport but it has way too many issues nobody wants to wait fxcking 6 years to see a fight with the best two fighters who are fighting in the same weight division that would NEVER EVER happen in the UFC it's an absolute joke this is why that company has tried to monopolize things so we can eventually force the best to fight the best.
And finally nobody wants to see a youth fight some 5 and 30 losses guy... NOBODY wants to see that shiet!!
Competition is drastically needed for these youth kids pit them against one another let the best succeed its a dog eat world you can't spoon feed an 18 year old ffs.
Spot on. Haymon has been killing boxing. I mean I'm all for fighters getting paid for but like you said they keep giving them a million to fight over matched opponents and now expect Mayweather or Manny money whenever the public wants them to step up and fight anybody good.
With Haymons money going dry and HBO cutting their budget and Showtime pretty much being a non factor since PBC started boxing is in really rough shape right now.
I'm just curious to see how you all view the current state of our sport.
Are we still in a transition period? A year after Floyd retired, we have a situation where the guys who are being touted as the best are either dragging smaller guys up, or are fighting guys who have no chance of winning, or both in some cases. We also a vacuum in the WW division which was dominated for years by Mayweather, which seemingly doesn't want to be filled or plugged, we've got Fury and Wlad going nowhere, etc.
On the flip side, we have Kov vs Ward coming up and Manny coming out of "retirement".
After the Floyd and Manny period (I'm reluctant to call it an era) of domination, are more years like 2016 all we have to look forward to now, or do you all foresee improvement, or further degradation of the sport. Also, if you feel things are going down, how would you turn things around?
Discuss below. Looking for a mature discussion of views and opinions. Fanboy/hater inspired vitriol is not needed.
Funny enough, it all started with Floyd and perfected by Pacman. That's how we're reached to this point. But there isn't a vacuum at ww. There are some fine fine ww's right now. We had Porter/One time this year. That was an excellent scrap. There's that young kat knocking heads. All we need is for Garcia to find his balls again. There's a lot of potential there, minus the afore mentioned Pacman still hanging around fighting c class fighters.
But all that needs to be said is Ward/Kova is going down. That's one of the most important fights in quite some time. Then the possibility of GGG/DJ. Another meaningful fight.
If the boxing fans would purge themselves of the infatuation with Floyd/Pacman's overrated ppv runs of fighting guys they know they could beat, (past down to canelo), and demand quality ppv's, if there are going to be ppv's, like Ward/Kova, we could get this ship righted.
Some people have canelo as a top 5 pfp fighter. That seems crazy, because he's not the best at 160, hell, is he even the best at 154?? Lets keep it real. Most people didn't think he beat Lara and who's actually convinced he beats the Charlo bwoys and the BooBoo?
I think it is being Humbled right now and I think it needs to hit Rock Bottom especially here in the US before picking itself back up. People only focus on PBC cutbacks but it is cutbacks going on all across boxing and even INVESTORS seems no longer interested in putting money into boxing
How would you rescue or rebuild boxing once rock bottom has been hit?
Personally, I would streamline the number belts, and create situations in which the top boxers are more or less forced into action. Create a tournament/league of sorts for every weight class, have the contenders fight, gain "points", fight the champ at the end. Perhaps two or "leagues" per weight class/governing body, and upon the conclusion of the "leagues", there is a... decider in which the champs fight each other. IBO v IBF, WBA v WBO in semis, then the winners of those fight each other in a final.
That way, there is constant interest, because we have people keeping score, we have top rated contenders fighting each other with some semblance of regularity to climb up the standings/ratings and become champs, etc.
Might be a logistical nightmare, but it would force the best to fight each other, and we wouldn't be forced to have champs fighting in made up weight classes and the like.
The sport is like the wild west if that's an accurate way to describe it there is no order to it all we have too many divisions, too many belts and a case of fighters/promoters not willing to negotiate with other promoters.
The problem with boxing is compare it to a UFC fight care and ask yourself these certain things about that fight card
Was the undercard entertaining
Did the undercard have competitive fights
Was the main-event a fight that should have happened
Now here is how it differs the answer most of the time for UFC is a big fat YES to all of those whereas with boxing the first two mainly are answered with no and 50% of the time with the main-event question being yes/no.
Now that is a problem obviously but there are loads of problems with boxing, boxing fans brag about how much more money their athletes get over UFC/MMA athletes but they completely skip the part about their athletes fighting guys they should be every fight so boxers being paid too much is definitely an issue why would a fighter want to fight someone good for a million dollars (which absolutely should be considered good money) when he can fight a bum like Alexander Brand and earn the same money whilst Brand gets $30k?
The fighters NEED to be forced into taking meaningful fights which leads to another problem... too many promotions and whatever way you want to look at it this is just an issue these guys rarely want to deal with each other because either one will make it impossible and maybe an odd one will be willing to negotiate.
UFC might be monopolized but If you ask people which is more entertaining I'm pretty certain UFC will win that vote most of the time too many greedy people in boxing ruining everything it's a great sport but it has way too many issues nobody wants to wait fxcking 6 years to see a fight with the best two fighters who are fighting in the same weight division that would NEVER EVER happen in the UFC it's an absolute joke this is why that company has tried to monopolize things so we can eventually force the best to fight the best.
And finally nobody wants to see a youth fight some 5 and 30 losses guy... NOBODY wants to see that shiet!!
Competition is drastically needed for these youth kids pit them against one another let the best succeed its a dog eat world you can't spoon feed an 18 year old ffs.
^^^^^ Nailed it
9y ago
What's Your Opinion On The Current State Of Boxing. | BoxingScene Community