Better resume..Zab Judah or Vitali Klitschko

Judah lost all the big fights even Baldimor beat him

Vote and discuss Remember that a resume includes all fighters that you have fought. It is not who ya beat.

Both their resumes suck but Vitali's is better than Zabs who never beat anyone but Cory Spinks and a very green Witter.

I don't feel too strongly either way, but beating Cory Spinks is probably better than anyone Vitali beat. Who exactly is Vitali's best win? Adamek? Peter? peter had a belt and wasn't shot back then and was considered extremely dangerous while vitali was coming off a huge layoff at 37. that and the sanders win dwarfs any Judah win plus vitali did make several title defenses at an advanced age. don't get me wrong,,,vitali's resume is far from great but it craps all over judahs imo

In both cases, their losses are actually more memorable than their wins. What do people remember Vitali Klitschko for? Putting up a good effort before getting his face mangled by Lennox Lewis What do people remember Zab Judah for? Chicken Dance/ "Don't ever play with matches" against Tyszu or winning the first 4 rounds against Mayweather. I don't feel too strongly either way, but beating Cory Spinks is probably better than anyone Vitali beat. Who exactly is Vitali's best win? Adamek? Peter?

In both cases, their losses are actually more memorable than their wins. What do people remember Vitali Klitschko for? Putting up a good effort before getting his face mangled by Lennox Lewis What do people remember Zab Judah for? Chicken Dance/ "Don't ever play with matches" against Tyszu or winning the first 4 rounds against Mayweather. Getting knocked out by Khan.

In both cases, their losses are actually more memorable than their wins. What do people remember Vitali Klitschko for? Putting up a good effort before getting his face mangled by Lennox Lewis What do people remember Zab Judah for? Chicken Dance/ "Don't ever play with matches" against Tyszu or winning the first 4 rounds against Mayweather.

vitali and its not even close. Judah is proof that it takes a hell of a lot more than just talent to be a dominating professional fighter. vitali's resume isn't great by any means but Judah's is terrible. lost almost every meaningful fight The irony of this line. :lol1:

This is a loaded question, the answer is Judah. Vitali fought in the weakest HW era in history where the biggest names were him and his brother. It's Zab by default, some of his losses are better than some of Vitalis wins, and that really says something about the division and era.

It's close, sadly. Edge to Klitschko, however.

Resume usually includes both wins and losses Zab fought some great guys, but alas victories over B opponents is better than one sided losses to A opponents

:sucks: :sucks: :sucks: :sucks:

So does Clottey suck to???? He lost to Baldomir as well His resume is pretty crappy yea. Throw in his pathetic performance against Pac and I'm not even sure why you would bring him up.

Resume is your entire body of work as a fighter, you can't just ignore losses. Judah has 9 of them and he lost to Baldomir. His resume fukin sucks. So does Clottey suck to???? He lost to Baldomir as well

Vote and discuss vitali and its not even close. Judah is proof that it takes a hell of a lot more than just talent to be a dominating professional fighter. vitali's resume isn't great by any means but Judah's is terrible. lost almost every meaningful fight

Not even sure what that means man..Resume=who you beat Resume is your entire body of work as a fighter, you can't just ignore losses. Judah has 9 of them and he lost to Baldomir. His resume fukin sucks.

Vitali's record is one of the worst in heavyweight history... he's like the Joe Calzaghe of the heavyweight division and his brother isn't that much better That being said Judah has too many losses

Judah's beat no one of note and never looked particularly good doing it. This isn't even a debate. I think it's time to come back from panama larry. I didnt vote for either nor am i saying Judah has the better resume..i have no opinion in this..just trying to make a different type of thread for debate

Judah's beat no one of note and never looked particularly good doing it. This isn't even a debate. I think it's time to come back from panama larry.

Vitali has the better resume. Judah lost to Baldomir /thread Not even sure what that means man..Resume=who you beat