Who's more deserving of a rematch with Danny Garcia Herrera or Matthysse?

everyone knows herrera is the real champ and beat garcia easy so question should be does garcia really deserve a rematch against herrera, especially after facing rod salka.. i dont think garcia deserves the rematch, herrera has bigger fish to fry and he already dominated garcia.

Herrera. He won more convincingly.

herrara beat and hurt garcia but got robbed

I saw Garcia beating both rather comfortably. I would go with Matthysse so he could take a giant dump on that horrible emotionally fueled fanbase once again and maybe even take some out for good. The majority of people who believe Herrera won are from south of the border, nothing wrong with that but you need to be objective when viewing fights. Al Bernstein and Steve Farhood are from way South of the border. FAR FAR SOUTH!

Herrera, simply because he BEAT Danny.

No they didn't, the media in attendance had it split right down the middle. That's not what a robbery is. http://www.badlefthook.com/2014/3/18/5523718/garcia-vs-herrera-scoring-70-of-boxing-media-scored-fight-for-herrera 70% of the media scored it for Herrera, only 12.5% thought Danny won. Herrera deserves the rematch more.

I don't know. It was pretty close imo. 7-5 I can respect this even though I disagree with it.

Entertaining is not always a reason for a rematch. The fight was not that close. Danny closed strong and won clearly, without question. Heerera deserves a chance to right a wrong. I don't know. It was pretty close imo. 7-5

Fukem both. Swift has much more important opponents on his agenda... http://media.tumblr.com/edbe850b56d408eb5a2f33d0b8459a77/tumblr_n4meflOQAy1rhavdko1_500.gif Hererra is more worthy though atm

Matthysse lost, but it was close. Close enough to warrant a rematch, as it would probably be another entertaining fight. Herrera should be the champ right now, though. So yeah. he should have gotten his rematch already. Entertaining is not always a reason for a rematch. The fight was not that close. Danny closed strong and won clearly, without question. Heerera deserves a chance to right a wrong.

As an Argentine I am, I would like a rematch with Matthysse. But I vote for the rematch against herrera, because the first was a robbery.

Herrera IMO won, he deserves a rematch b/c of terrible judging. Matthysse does not. he lost clearly. Matthysse lost, but it was close. Close enough to warrant a rematch, as it would probably be another entertaining fight. Herrera should be the champ right now, though. So yeah. he should have gotten his rematch already.

Herrera IMO won, he deserves a rematch b/c of terrible judging. Matthysse does not. he lost clearly.

You can make an argument for both, to be honest. Argument for: Herrera- He should've won on the cards the first time, let him avenge his loss! Matthysse- There's a bit of drama here with many pointing at the puffy eye as the downfall in the fight AND the first fight was great. Let's see another one. Argument against: Herrera- He won the first time and CLEARLY, why would we want to see it again? Matthysse- Garcia won the first fight, albeit a close fight, clearly and Garcia will do the same again. There's a compelling argument for both sides but I wouldn't mind either rematch.

You're saying it like there's a choice between one or the other for his next fight

While Herrera gave Garcia fits all night and deserves the rematch because of the controversial scoring, I'm sure most would rather see a rematch with Matthysse or at the very least, would say both. Who would not want to see a rematch with Garcia vs Mat?

One guy arguably beat him. The other clearly lost. Pretty simple.

Would like to see rematches for both but herrera won his fight vs garcia so of course he deserves it more.

^^^^^^^ Exactly. Bigger and better fights on the horizon. Only certain demographics care to see these dull ass matches. That being said Swift ez work with lucas and we'll have a dejavu of salka vs el matador or whatever the fuk his name is... This was the reason he gave for not rematching Herrera last fight. Boy did we get bigger and better things that time

He doesnt want it with El Maestro again. At welter this boy is taking some losses. Perhaps like all champs but @147 he'll whip some ass as well...