Shawn Porter vs Maidana...who takes it?

Maidana won't be holding like Brook when Porter rushes in.....this would be a brutal fight that would be over in 7-8 rounds....my $$ would be on Maidana.

he is winning the poll though which is surprising. i think porter's over-aggressiveness will be the death of him against maidana. because despite maidana's brawler reputation, he actually knows distancing and timing. We knew that, but Broner, Floyd, and a million casual fans believed that nonsense. :lol1: Maidana will box your ears off.

Maidana is much better defensively, porter would leave himself too wide open and Maidana would be able to land bombs more often than not

Maidana losses every fantasy fight. I just want to see Porter trying to wrestle Maidana after Chino lands his overhand from the sky he is winning the poll though which is surprising. i think porter's over-aggressiveness will be the death of him against maidana. because despite maidana's brawler reputation, he actually knows distancing and timing.

Maidana losses every fantasy fight. I just want to see Porter trying to wrestle Maidana after Chino lands his overhand from the sky Porter would fight ferociously until Maidana hits him with a solid right and makes him do the booty dew like AB did, then he will go out on his shield very quickly.

Maidana losses every fantasy fight. I just want to see Porter trying to wrestle Maidana after Chino lands his overhand from the sky

I've got Porter on this one.

Maidana would brutally stop Porter, I don't think it would be close, it would be a war early on but asking Porter to trade with Maidana is like asking a pit bull to fight a lion.

would be interesting to see the two standing next to each other to look at how they compare size wise

I think Maidana would edge Porter. This could be FOTY though

Porter beats the crap out of Maidana.

Maidana by KO.

I'm not sure but I'd LOVE to watch it. I guess I'd pick Maidana. But as usual, I'm sure it's just fantasy on our part.

Porter ud's him......porter is one dimensional but he's a more athletic version of maidana.

Porter charges in throwing hooks to the head and body. That's the kind of fight Maidana likes and he is a little better at it than Porter. His hands are a bit faster, he punches harder and has a larger variety of punches coming in from different angles. He also has a higher work rate I think. Porter wouldn't have to worry about Maidana holding him. Maidana would slug it out with him and win.

Accidentally hit Porter.

Maidana has a big edge in power. Porter isn't the type of fighter he typically struggles with. MM by a clear decision.

I don't think Maidana has the mentality or skill to box anyones ears off...lol he is a brawler with a decent jab welp, then we agree to disagree on that, I think that's straight disrespect to Maidana and he has proven he isn't some mindless face first brawler. lol people think Maidana could outbox Porter? Absolute madness. Maidana is a face-first robot with no boxing ability. I would pick Porter to win by UD. http://cache.backpackinglight.com/backpackinglight/user_uploads/1293235182_34438.gif

I like Maidana in this fight. I think Maidana tastes the canvass once then stops Brook. well Brook wouldn't be fighting..lol..unless he jumped in with an iron chair or something

He outboxed Broner and this cant be disputed! :boxing: No he didn't he mauled him and beat him up