Cotto vs Maravilla: Who won against better competition?

cotto..............are we really bigging up a chavez jr win? compared to guys like CLOTTEY? what in the total f*ck has happened to this board. when i see people bigging up a fat lazy fighter like chavez jr (when compared with guys like mosley, clottey, pauli, judah,) thats when I Know I've left planet earth.............cotto gets a lot of hate on these forums but in realty his resume is 100 times better then guys like martinez.

Barely OK. Cotto was on cruise control throughout, and still easily won every round. Mayorga was game but he was never really in the fight. As for the comparison, Martinez's best wins are better, but Cotto's resume is much deeper. Overall, I give the slight edge to Cotto. Martinez will beat him though. Poster should have compared total careers, not a few fights. Cotto has fought better fighters even coming up. And i agree im a fan but i feel Martinez size is to much.

Yeah? It was an ok fight. Barely OK. Cotto was on cruise control throughout, and still easily won every round. Mayorga was game but he was never really in the fight. As for the comparison, Martinez's best wins are better, but Cotto's resume is much deeper. Overall, I give the slight edge to Cotto. Martinez will beat him though.

Cotto fought Mayorga? He fought him after Foreman and before Margarito 2.

Cotto fought Mayorga? Yeah? It was an ok fight.

Martínez win over Chávez is underated

Cottos best win is past prime Mosley, it's a good win. Judah and Clottey are also pretty good wins. Martinez biggest win is Williams, a good win at the time. Pavlik and Chavez jr also good wins. Got to go with Martinez.

*Cotto vs Maravilla: who won against better competition? Alright guys quick question: Who had the better competition and actually won the fight? Cotto, evidently went against better competition like Floyd and Manny, but he didnt won those fight.* Sergio: Bunema Williams Pavlik Dzinziruk Barker Macklin Chavez JR Murray Cotto: Judah Jenkins Mosley Clottey Margarito Mayorga Paulie Rodriguez *** This is such a stupid question, you are either blatantly trolling or are not a real boxing fan or both. It's Cotto and it's not close, nor a real discussion.

Martinez won most of his big fights and Cotto lost almost all of his.