Maidana or Matthysee: Who ya got?

Maidana, he's just a better fighter. Both can punch, both can be hit, but Marcos sets up his punches, and can just swarm you. I think he'd bully and frustrate Lucas.

Matthysse:boxing::boxing:

Matthysse stops Maidana.

Lucas seems a little more sturdy and like he hits a little harder and seems to be a little cagier with rolling and parrying punches so I'd have him at 140. I dont know how Lucas seems at 147 as he seems a bit smaller naturally than Marcos. Still, I'd pick Lucas. come on bro..............

Maidana stops him in 3

Maidana is bigger.and nastier. Lucas belongs at 140 and not as durable

Madonna knocks out mathy B- vs C+ or C+ vs C-

Maidana by a mile. Maidana's power would be way too much for Matthysse. If Molina can put Matthysse down twice, Maidana would knock him out.

Yes, they were at different weight classes, but one guy beat Alexander, and the other guy got routed by Alexander. Also, you're talking about possibly the best body puncher in boxing against someone with a semi weakness to brutal body punches. I'm going with Matthysse, even at WW. hahahahaha

This fight has to happen.

:dunce: :lol1::lol1:

Tough call, but I think Lucas takes it. His work to the body would be a nightmare for Maidana. Much rather go on watching them face other fighters though.

hope this **** doesnt happen no need for the fight and GB wants to push for it cause they are sleezy

neither of these guys, who are close friends, are interested in fighting each other right now so their decisions should be respected. they are asked constantly about this fight and rich schaefer has an ultimate hard on for making it. i bet it gets annoying. the fight should have some sort of meaning and or greater incentive behind it other than bloodthirsty fans simply wanting to see two guys limiting their careers.

Totally true,, can't take amateur success and think it will happen in pros,, sometimes it does with oscar-Shane, Shane-Forrest, or it doesn't like porter-Devon... But the interview with Lucas saying he didn't want none, "on different paths" it's a sign he isn't very confident vs maidana Or Roy vs Tarver but like you I have feeling neither are in rush to fight each other.

matthysse has better fundamentals. maidana i think punches just a tiny bit harder Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Devon owned Shawn Porter in the amateurs but Porter undressed him as a professional. So wouldn't use that but you may be right. Totally true,, can't take amateur success and think it will happen in pros,, sometimes it does with oscar-Shane, Shane-Forrest, or it doesn't like porter-Devon... But the interview with Lucas saying he didn't want none, "on different paths" it's a sign he isn't very confident vs maidana

Honestly,, Maidana owned Lucas in the amateurs, and last year when Lucas was asked about a Maidana fight, Lucas didn't want known and said some crap about going different paths.... Lucas don't want none of Maidana..... Devon owned Shawn Porter in the amateurs but Porter undressed him as a professional. So wouldn't use that but you may be right.

Matthysse UD. Lucas does everything better. Maidana has only one advantage: he is bigger.

Honestly,, Maidana owned Lucas in the amateurs, and last year when Lucas was asked about a Maidana fight, Lucas didn't want known and said some crap about going different paths.... Lucas don't want none of Maidana.....