I think Malignaggi beats Garcia. What you think?

Yea that could be true. Danny is one of those fighters that has high IQ he can win fights without looking impressive. But that's against fighters who are are brawlers, or Khan who seems to have low IQ. But we've seen instances, like against Ashley Theopane, Khan (first two rounds) and now Herrera that he's going to struggle with boxers. So down the line we have to ask ourselves who can he beat? Also I thought the Matthysse fight was close too. But I'm just making a general point. I don't think there's a top fighter that we can say he'll definitely beat. He'll make for a lot of competitive match-ups, which is a good thing. I would like to see him vs. Guerrero especially. I think anyone who's watched a few of Herrera's fights wasn't too surprised with how effective he was against Garcia. If there's anything to take away from tonight, it's that Herrera refuses to be an easy stepping stone for anyone.

Did CJ ross replicate herself twice for the judging?

Though he beat them, I wouldn't say he excelled against them. Morales was faded by that point, but he did remain competitive in the first bout and it was because of his ring IQ. Even-though some like to pretend otherwise, Garcia barely beat Matts. DG will win his fair share of fights, but I think he'll rarely look impressive/dominant in victory. Yea that could be true. Danny is one of those fighters that has high IQ he can win fights without looking impressive. But that's against fighters who are are brawlers, or Khan who seems to have low IQ. But we've seen instances, like against Ashley Theopane, Khan (first two rounds) and now Herrera that he's going to struggle with boxers. So down the line we have to ask ourselves who can he beat? Also I thought the Matthysse fight was close too. But I'm just making a general point.

who the fck is danny garcia gonna beat at 147? shoulda taken the mayweather fight, hes going to lose *AGAIN* very soon

Said it since day one. Paulie gives him fits.

I think Garcia has problems with boxers. As Dwyer would say he's a "mid-range hooker", that's all he really throws. Against brawlers like Morales and Matthysse, he can excel. But the first two rounds against Amir Khan and against Herrera we see that fighters with a jab that throw straight punches give him problems. I think he needs to stay away from boxers. Paulie would likely give him a lot of trouble. I thought Herrera won the fight, but it is what it is. Though he beat them, I wouldn't say he excelled against them. Morales was faded by that point, but he did remain competitive in the first bout and it was because of his ring IQ. Even-though some like to pretend otherwise, Garcia barely beat Matts. DG will win his fair share of fights, but I think he'll rarely look impressive/dominant in victory.

I think Garcia has problems with boxers. As Dwyer would say he's a "mid-range hooker", that's all he really throws. Against brawlers like Morales and Matthysse, he can excel. But the first two rounds against Amir Khan and against Herrera we see that fighters with a jab that throw straight punches give him problems. I think he needs to stay away from boxers. Paulie would likely give him a lot of trouble. I thought Herrera won the fight, but it is what it is. Erik Morales is leagues above Malignaggi as a boxer. If you or anyone else think differently then there is a serious problem here. He is not, nor has he ever been, a "brawler."

paulie b***** slaps him now and then and wins on points. paulie would lose just off the hype of danny throwing a punch, im sorry but this is what boxing has come to

I think Garcia has problems with boxers. As Dwyer would say he's a "mid-range hooker", that's all he really throws. Against brawlers like Morales and Matthysse, he can excel. But the first two rounds against Amir Khan and against Herrera we see that fighters with a jab that throw straight punches give him problems. I think he needs to stay away from boxers. Paulie would likely give him a lot of trouble. I thought Herrera won the fight, but it is what it is.

anyone with 2 eyes and a brain(sorry khan) beats garcia easy

Yup. Paulie woops him too

Nope, he's not a tricky match up at all for Garcia, or hardly anyone at the top of 140. Paulie defense is not that good, has no power to keep Garcia honest. Herrera was a problem for Danny because he was on him all night. Paulie wouldn't be trading blows with Garcia lol Just to clear it up you saw this victory as a robbery right?

I've always thought so because Paulie doesn't stand in front of guys and that's what Garcia thrives on. Would be competitive.

Paulie beat dannys ass

No. Herrera is much better defensively.

I would pick Garcia against Paulie, but he wouldn't look good doing it. Paulie has one of the most educated jabs in boxing with nice feints. I don't think he's that great defensively though, but he isn't devoid of defense. He can also take a punch. His lack of power would lead to him taking the L.

i agree, and i also thought herrara did better against garcia because i thought he actually lost to provodnikov

Do people not realize Herrara is a tricky match up for a lot of guys and has beat guys like Ruslan Provodnikov? So because of that Paulie beats Garcia? It's like Garcia beating Khan and Matthysse didn't happen? So Paulie is not a tricky matchup? Hes not using his legs and jab? Doesnt have a good defense?

A decent chin and an ability to stick to the plan. Perhap judges on your side too?

When has Malignaggi ever had good defence? Unlike Herrera, Malignaggi doesn't have any semblance of head movement. Malignaggi has a mouth and little else.