Pacquaio ranks higher than Mayweather Jr. in the ATG list.

hell no.he's not even ATG material or future hall of famer...pacman is one dimensional fighter and i dont think floyd is ATG also ATG status is based on resume and achievements. Floyds a better pure boxer but IMO Pac has achieved more.

Your sig wins. Lengthened my life by 2 years. :boobies:

Then by your logic Pac-juice should not be an all time great fighter because he has a long list of fighters he ducked;for example:Nate Campbell,Juan Diaz,Juan Guzman,Zahir Raheem,Yuri Foremen,Rafael Marquez,Mark Too Sharp Johnson,Tim Austin,Mayweather back in 2010,Mosley back in 2009(waited till Mosley was shot to fight him) You Pac groupies should have been in the movie Dumb and Dumber. Is this your version of reverse phycology or something, people call Floyd the biggest ducker in history, so we will say the same thing about Pac. Only thing it doesn't work is your problem, because when you are the opposite of Floyd, fighting two times a year, tough competition, you can hardly be called a ducker can you? Pac has been renowned for having a tremendously tough era of fights since beating Barrera first time round. Yet you can say Pac is a ducker, it don't work like that im afraid to put it to you. Pac ducked Raheem for Morales instead?. That's like saying you ducked Randolph turpin for SRR instead, and youd be a ducking coward for fighting SRR?

Of course Pac. Only reason otherwise is the list is made up by Americans, and Pac is as American as the N. Korean president. Your sig wins.

Of course Pac. Only reason otherwise is the list is made up by Americans, and Pac is as American as the N. Korean president.

Of course. Where's the other thread that had Pac winning by 200 votes?

How many times has this very thread been recycled? Hell its probably been brought up dozens of times already this year

you cant duck fights and be considered an ATG. Thats not how it works! Most of all the greatest boxers who have ever lived has got losses on their record. They got them by fighting the best out there and taking on dangerous opponents. Not by paying off, cherry picking and ducking fighters. That is a COWARDS way. Then by your logic Pac-juice should not be an all time great fighter because he has a long list of fighters he ducked;for example:Nate Campbell,Juan Diaz,Juan Guzman,Zahir Raheem,Yuri Foremen,Rafael Marquez,Mark Too Sharp Johnson,Tim Austin,Mayweather back in 2010,Mosley back in 2009(waited till Mosley was shot to fight him) You Pac groupies should have been in the movie Dumb and Dumber.

Pac is more popular than Floyd Mayweather is so of course he would lead this poll.

**** no. Pac man is way far behind. THats why you have guys listing floyd in the top five. Some saying number one. whether you believe that or not you never hear that about pac at all lol what guys? Larryx and the big dung? give me a break no one lists him at number 1 you'd have to be an all time bumsniffer:fing26::*******:

How on earth can you not fight the best fighter on the planet in your era and in your weight-class yet be considered higher as an ATG? :lol1: Well said. This is the truth and only hypocrite fanboys ignores this:*******:

No. Mayweather is top 40, Manny top 50.

pac is way ahead of floyd in the atg list and even fraud and his ex-convict clan will agree on it.

:qqq::qqq::qqq: You do realize he is talking about pac hahahahahahah

**** no. Pac man is way far behind. THats why you have guys listing floyd in the top five. Some saying number one. whether you believe that or not you never hear that about pac at all

What a shit thread with shit poll results. I'm a Pac fan and dislike Mayweather. Mayweather is clearly without question; deserved P4P #1 and will be higher on most ATG lists. Pac's resume and accomplishments take a steamer all over Floyd's and I don't think that's really in question here.

He does , I still have a problem with Floyd turning down the rematch with Oscar and the retirement when the division had so many good talent

Yes.................. At the moment, assuming Floyd really retires at the end of 2015, there's nothing he can do aside from beating Pacquiao himself to close the gap. (Maybe beating GGG would do the same, IDK)

When Floyd became relevant and somebody in boxing, he fought less and less....how convenient. Its because you have to fight better boxers as its expected and it gets harder. Fighting even once a year was an ordeal for him, don't let his recent fights fool you. That's why Floyd went AWOL for long periods, while Pac cleaned up for him. Pac will go down as a highter ATG unless Floyd shows he wants to be above. It will not be possible to not notice it, if Floyd wants it. He will stop messing aboiut with whether its going to be khan or maidana nonsense. WHo is Pac fight next? Bradley. There you have it....speaks for itself.

No, but not fighting him hurts Mayweather's legacy. A lot of people think Mayweather's ducking but I don't think most of them think Pacquiao is better. The fight not happening hurts Mayweather more too because he's held to a higher standard than Pacquiao since he's supposed to be better.