Fights You Scored Differently Than the Vast Majority

I've always thought Quartey got robbed against Oscar. Seemed clear to me. Have never understood how Pac/Marquez 3 is called a robbery. I'm very surprised Chavez Jr./Vera is considered a robbery. I can see a legit way to score it for Chavez.

I believe that : Canelo defeated Mayweather Alexander defeated Matthysse Barrera defeated Marquez Khan defeated Peterson Castillo defeated Mayweather

All of my draws: Cotto-Mosley draw Bradley-Pac draw Trout-Cotto draw Marquez-Bradley draw Broner-Malignaggi draw Kessler-Froch II draw Others: Clottey over Cotto Calzaghe over Hopkins Williams over Martinez I Murray over Martinez* Canelo over Trout Lara over Molina Marquez over John Judah over Matthysse Ortiz over Peterson Khan over Peterson LOL are you serious? Did you also have Castillo over Mayweather? And did you have the unpopular opinion of Whitaker beating Chavez too? I think the majority felt Ike beat DLH. Relax, guy. I remember seeing polls on here where the majority felt Oscar pulled it out w/ his 12th round rally. I actually had Castillo/Mayweather a draw. Perfect examples for the most part btw, that's what I was looking for. Not sure why you felt the need to try and take a shot though. I thought Khan clearly beat Peterson as well...even including the BS deductions.

Im talking the fights that are the proverbial "close but clear" fights that you strongly feel should have gone the other way. Thought it'd be interesting to see the close fights that people scored differently than most. Just two that come off the top of my head: I felt Quartey clearly beat Oscar I felt Marquez edged Bradley. The Marquez Bradley fight sticks out for me. I thought Bradley edged it out by 2points but you gotta be careful with the hbo crew they really can persuade the way u see fights especially the casual fans. They like to make fights seem one sided.

I had Pacquiao - Bradley much closer than many, although I do think Pacquiao won. Maidana beat Khan Marquez beat Bradley. Malignaggi beat Broner.

actually scored 5 rounds for canelo vs wayweater due to body shots ..... oscar did not beat felix sturm broner did not beat paulie canelo did not beat trout trout - cotto was a draw mayweather by landslide UD over ODLH (whooped his ass) vanes-andrade was a draw

I had PAC/Bradley a draw

I had Sweet Pea beating Oscar De La Hoya De la Hoya over Mayweather, Tito & Mosley (rematch) Clotey vs Cotto a draw I know some people say Hagler got robbed against SRL, but I think SRL clearly won. Provodnikov beat Bradley IMO as well Bazooka vs ODH draw

I had Trout beating Lara by 2 points. And Ricardo Cordoba was definitely robbed against Rigondeaux.

Castillo definitely beat Floyd

Yeah, the majority had Mayweather beating Castillo :lol1: Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=411843&page=1 Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won?? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=576019 Who really won Castillo vs Mayweather 1 (Public Poll) http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=205607 Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=117481 Just re-watched Mayweather-Castillo 1 http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=444939 Rewatched Mayweather VS Castillo 1, Never seen Floyd look so lost http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=567417 Was Castillo robbed of a victory over Floyd Mayweather Jr.? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=84379 Flyod vs Castillo - 1st Match Poll ; Who Won? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=389608 Poll: Floyd v. Castillo I...who won? http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=144442 No way mayweather won the 1st castillo fight http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=254413

Castillo beat Floyd. fight was even at stoppage of Lewis / Clitko

I had Cotto, Guerrerro and Canelo all beating floyd I had Ortiz up until the sucker punch I had JMM over Bradley

I would say that the majority agree with you on that one. I don't know how Peterson got that draw. I thought Ortiz beat up Peterson for the majority of the 10 rounder, including the couple of KD's. It should have been a win. Peterson had some success in 3-4 rounds tops, but Ortiz won like 5-6 clearly, with the KD's that's a win.

Another one. Sorry man, we are cool but It's okay to argue still. These are not decisions agreed upon by the "vast majority". Any one you ask thinks Matthysse won both fights. Ah I see what you mean. Not necessarily fight where the judges got it wrong, but fights where you saw it different than EVERYONE. In that case, Froch beating Dirrell off the top of my mind. I know everyone says Dre clearly won, but I scored that fight for Froch live and always have on my rewatches.

All of my draws: Cotto-Mosley draw Bradley-Pac draw Trout-Cotto draw Marquez-Bradley draw Broner-Malignaggi draw Kessler-Froch II draw Others: Clottey over Cotto Calzaghe over Hopkins Williams over Martinez I Murray over Martinez* Canelo over Trout Lara over Molina Marquez over John Judah over Matthysse Ortiz over Peterson Khan over Peterson LOL are you serious? Did you also have Castillo over Mayweather? And did you have the unpopular opinion of Whitaker beating Chavez too? I think the majority felt Ike beat DLH. I would say that the majority agree with you on that one.

Matthysse clearly beat Judah and Alexander. Very clearly. Garica fight was close and the KD round was what lost it for him on the cards. Another one. Sorry man, we are cool but It's okay to argue still. These are not decisions agreed upon by the "vast majority". Any one you ask thinks Matthysse won both fights.

All of my draws: Cotto-Mosley draw Bradley-Pac draw Trout-Cotto draw Marquez-Bradley draw Broner-Malignaggi draw Kessler-Froch II draw Others: Clottey over Cotto Calzaghe over Hopkins Williams over Martinez I Murray over Martinez* Canelo over Trout Lara over Molina Marquez over John Judah over Matthysse Ortiz over Peterson Khan over Peterson Im talking the fights that are the proverbial "close but clear" fights that you strongly feel should have gone the other way. Thought it'd be interesting to see the close fights that people scored differently than most. Just two that come off the top of my head: I felt Quartey clearly beat Oscar I felt Marquez edged Bradley. LOL are you serious? Did you also have Castillo over Mayweather? And did you have the unpopular opinion of Whitaker beating Chavez too? I think the majority felt Ike beat DLH.

i had Castillo by 4pts over Floyd Marquez by 3 Over Pac in their 3rd fight

Matthysse clearly beat Judah and Alexander. Very clearly. Garica fight was close and the KD round was what lost it for him on the cards.