Is Cotto vs Martinez really a legit fight?

You make some fair points. I never thought Cotto was shot. He gave Trout all he could handle and he gave Floyd a tough fight. I just want to point out the hypocrisy on this site is all. IMO Sergio got a little too much hype after the P-Will KO (just like JMM). He was still a top P4P guy but i think a bit overrated. Cotto was prematurely called washed up and dismissed. Good legit fight. Both are action guys who are a bit chinny.

your right, but things have changed,,, cotto is shop-worn and couldnt handle any fresh world class top level guys anymore like floyd, manny, canelo, trout, but serg looked older than hopkins in his last fight vs murray, now serg will have a year layoff and cotto is looking motivated and young again.... would i rather see serg vs ggg or quillen,, yes but i dont mind cotto-serg,,,,, both will get big money and should be an entertaining fight,, You make some fair points. I never thought Cotto was shot. He gave Trout all he could handle and he gave Floyd a tough fight. I just want to point out the hypocrisy on this site is all.

I think Martinez is too old now. He looked like crap in his last fight. If cotto fight and beats him he better fight ggg or quillin afterwards Lol no he does not have to. With the Martinez fight is just a "let me try to make history and go back down". Of course Golovkin would be licking his chops at the thought of getting the smaller Cotto in the ring while he(Golovkin) is in his prime and the much bigger, more powerful fighter. But I don't see Golovkin's team dying to go to 168 and calling out Ward, Froch, Kessler. Cotto fighting Martinez at 160 is already fighting more of a threat than GGG going up to 168. Keep in mind, Cotto started at 140, fighting at 160 is 20lbs north of his debut. Golovkin fighting Ward is a mere 8lbs from his debut weight. Golovkin would have to fight at Cruiserweight to match what guys like Mayweather, Pacquiao, Cotto are doing. How about he fights Murray, who's a big Middleweight, or goes to 168 to fight Ward or Froch? From what I heard, his manager isn't ready for Ward right now.

Legit fight. 50/50. Sergio aging and coming off injuries and Cotto is inconsistent. We never know what Cotto we're going to get. Shot Cotto? Recharged Cotto? New Trainer Cotto? Sergio Martinez is close to becoming the new Shane Mosley. It'll be a good resume name but the dude from a few years ago and legitimate #3 P4P guy is no more. I'd pay for Sergio vs. Cotto with the winner getting GGG or Mayweather at 160.

This fight was legit before he destroyed Rodriguez. You'll see when he stops Sergio.

I think Martinez is too old now. He looked like crap in his last fight. If cotto fight and beats him he better fight ggg or quillin afterwards

Martinez would have to be shot to bits for Cotto to stand any chance. If Martinez has anything left he knocks Cotto into next week.

To me, yes, it is legit. Reason, Sergio Martinez has slipped pretty bad. Also, Cotto's losing performances against Trout and Mayweather>Martinez's winning performances against Murray(Which I thought he lost), almost getting knocked by a limited Chavez, struggling with Macklin. This isn't even with with the TKO win over the overmatched Rodriguez. I did not take that performance into consideration at all. It meant nothing to me. His losses against Trout and Mayweather showed me more about what he has to offer vs Martinez.

I could've sworn last year Cotto was a shot blown up WW. Now every body is talking like they want this fight to happen. As for myself I wouldn't mind seeing it at 154. your right, but things have changed,,, cotto is shop-worn and couldnt handle any fresh world class top level guys anymore like floyd, manny, canelo, trout, but serg looked older than hopkins in his last fight vs murray, now serg will have a year layoff and cotto is looking motivated and young again.... would i rather see serg vs ggg or quillen,, yes but i dont mind cotto-serg,,,,, both will get big money and should be an entertaining fight,,

Make the fight!

Stop crying you disgruntled Mayweather fan. Face it your boy gets no credit on this site. Period. I didn't even mention Floyd's name and your already all over him. Besides you've been on this site a week. Know your role.

Cotto is trying to do something historical and symbolic for his country and Sergio would be an idiot for fighting a killer like GGG coming off back to back knee surgeries, inactivity and broken hands. So yes its a legit fight and a big event.

No! Hell no! Cotto is shot and is just treading on his name now. I like cotto and always have liked him but beating delvin shouldnt get you shot at MW champ especially when everyone says hes small for JMW and has never fought at MW.

I could've sworn last year Cotto was a shot blown up WW. Now every body is talking like they want this fight to happen. As for myself I wouldn't mind seeing it at 154. Stop crying you disgruntled Mayweather fan. Face it your boy gets no credit on this site. Period.

Depends on weight and what Sergio has left. That's the reason I think people would get excited, Sergio may be faded enough for Cotto to win.