if Canelo Wins, Is it fair to give him Pound4Pound No1?

if Not Stays with Floyd, Then Ward? Becuase ... "Hense" Pound4Pound: Has Canelo beat anyone of "NOTE" in more than one weight class? Has Canelo fought enough Opponents of "NOTE" in hes own weight class? Has Canelo Fought anyone 20 pounds Bigger than himself and still got the Win? Will Canelo move up even dare Step in the ring with a Big name at 160 or 170 or 175? Because Floyd Mayweather has been doing this since lightweight "Hense P4P Best" ..And until Canelo stops making welterweights fight him at 154 and starts beating big names of NOTE in his division and upwards. It is not fair to give him P4P for beating Floyd with over 20 pound weight Advantage. Maybe the Best at 154 is better, But even that can be tested. What you think?

Comments (12)

cantor5150

Nope but definitaly top3 I don't think he would move up to one but maybe crack the top five, but I don't think he will beat Money! Off topic but Who are those fighters on your sig? That is hilarious lol I want to know what happen or just watch the whole fight :boxing:

12y ago

boliodogs

PFP is a matter of opinion so if someone think he is the best fighter in the world for his weight then he is #1. Usually a fighter gets to be considered #1 PFP by many good wins and not just one great win. Mayweather fought his way to the top spot with many good wins and no loses. I think a win over Floyd at 152 pounds would put Canelo in the top 5 to me. Another very good win or two might make him #1 but again it depends on who is doing the rating. My gut tells me GGG might be the best fighter in the world PFP and I have not seen him on anybody else's list. Matthysse is right up near the top of my list as is Rigo.

12y ago

kiDynamite92

I'll give him more credit if he outboxes Mayweather to a decision. If it's a one punch knockout type of thing, will probably have more to do with the weight difference than p4p skill. Yeah pretty much. If he did KO Floyd and wanted to be ranked number 1, he would have to do it at 147 or at a resonably rehydrated weight

12y ago

Redd_Foxx

You think beating Mayweather is a bigger accomplishment than clearing out your division like Ward has? Hell no.

12y ago

Ezzard_Charles

if hhhahahahahahah

12y ago

BROOKLYN_CESAR

He needs way more big wins before he is number one!!!

12y ago

BajanXLegend

#3 behind Marquez and Ward Can Marquez ever be ranked above Mayweather? Remember Pacquiao is still a Pound4Pounder.

12y ago

DoktorSleepless

I'll give him more credit if he outboxes Mayweather to a decision. If it's a one punch knockout type of thing, will probably have more to do with the weight difference than p4p skill.

12y ago

Szef

Nope but definitaly top3

12y ago

LeG00N

#3 behind Marquez and Ward

12y ago

soul_survivor

I DON'T MIND IF SOMEONE RANKS HIM P4P NO. 1 if he beats Floyd but personally I wouldn't. It would be between JMM and Martinez for the number one spot.

12y ago

Weebler_I

I think he would move into the top 5. How many top 10 wins would he have? Rhodes, Trout and Mayweather? that's not too many.

12y ago