Broner ranked #5 P4P by ring magazine WTF?

Being biased here but Brian Viloria should at least be #10. I agree, I thought Viloria should've been in the top ten. Apparently, now the pound for pound ratings will just be to Chuck Giampa's discretion, though I'm told our input will be considered as normal in the regular divisional ratings. I think nothing of the whole pound-for-pound thing, but I think Giampa is utterly daft.

Does he actually? Or do all the writers do a vote? According to their site, Chuck Giampa is solely responsible for their P4P stuff.

:lol1: GBP has no shame...still my fav company though!!!

goldenboy owns the ring if you show up with enough unmarked money in a suitcase they'll almost certainly do whatever you want with their magazine Bingo. :boxing:

Ponce? Most people thought he lost that fight. I thought it was a draw. The early rounds were Ponce's, the middle were Broner's, and late neither guy really separated himself. Before the DeMarco fight, there were loads of people saying Broner would be exposed by a southpaw who's got height on him and that Broner wasn't really that good. He destroyed him, and now we still have people saying Broner doesn't have a good win yet. Broner shouldn't be Top 10 though, he should have to get at least a couple more good wins before getting into the Top 10.

Broner doesn't deserve to be in the Top 10, but I already see people forgetting he completely whupped DeMarco, the #1 LW at the time. He shouldn't be in the Top 10, but he has a couple good wins over DeMarco and Ponce. DeMarco was a decent fighter though, nothing more. Broner has a lot of skills, but we don't know how good they are until he puts them on display against an actual top fighter. As has been mentioned, Berto was looking like a superstar at that level. As for the Ponce 'win', that was a pretty clear loss in truth.

Broner doesn't deserve to be in the Top 10, but I already see people forgetting he completely whupped DeMarco, the #1 LW at the time. He shouldn't be in the Top 10, but he has a couple good wins over DeMarco and Ponce. Ponce? Most people thought he lost that fight.

The Ring has been reduced to little more than a promoters marketing pamphlet.

Broner doesn't deserve to be in the Top 10, but I already see people forgetting he completely whupped DeMarco, the #1 LW at the time. He shouldn't be in the Top 10, but he has a couple good wins over DeMarco and Ponce.

P4P who you "think" has the best skills, not who you've beat. Broner deserves top ten. If Broner belongs there, why don't we put Canelo Alvarez in at #6 or Peter Quillin at #7? Oh yeah, because in order to be considered one of the best you actually have to beat someone who's worth a damn. How can we really know if Broner is one of the ten best fighters if he hasn't gotten a big win? Berto was looking really dominant against tomato cans until he started facing the A-level opposition, did he deserve a spot there too?

goldenboy owns the ring if you show up with enough unmarked money in a suitcase they'll almost certainly do whatever you want with their magazine

P4P who you "think" has the best skills, not who you've beat. Broner deserves top ten.

LOL! What a joke!

1. Mayweather 2. Marquez 3. Ward 4. Martinez 5. Donaire 6. Wlad 7. Pacquiao 8. Mares 9. Froch 10. Bradley Vitali, Broner, Guerrero, Garcia, Trout, all out side the Top 10.

1. Mayweather 2. Marquez 3. Ward 4. Martinez 5. Donaire 6. Wlad 7. Pacquiao 8. Mares 9. Froch 10. Bradley Vitali, Broner, Guerrero, Garcia, Trout, all out side the Top 10.

We all know who has the #1 spot. Don't hate.

Adrien Broner at #5 and Carl Froch not even on the list... Ring Magazine, just f*ck off.

p4p lists don't judge accomplishments, they judge FORM. Current form. That's why people drop when they lose and go up when they win. And Broner is one of the best if not the best young fighter coming up. So it's ok for me he makes #5. Sorry, I just looked at your post history. Carry on arse-licking.

p4p lists don't judge accomplishments, they judge FORM. Current form. That's why people drop when they lose and go up when they win. And Broner is one of the best if not the best young fighter coming up. So it's ok for me he makes #5. For beating Antonio DeMarco? Will you go away and have a talk with yourself you flute.

Pacquiao will have no mercy on Broner at 147lbs. Pacquiao by brutal decapitation.