Donaire should be fighter of the year hands down

If Nonito had dominated Vasquez Jr/Mathebula, I think he would all agree that he deserves FOTY.

when you caught a fade, did they bald fade your brain matter too? log off and never post again smdh..... Your opinion is **** :lol1: :bottle: People like you two are the ones hurting this damn forum. People can't have a ****!ng opinion on here. The man was posting what HE thought was FOTY. The poster stated an opinion and he disagreed. I see no ****!ing problem with that. You people need to grow the fu(k up!

yeah and sergio dominated both guys so i wouldnt be mad if serg got it He didn't dominate Macklin. And Macklin isn't even really top class neither is Chavez. I'd say Nishioka is probably a better win than those combined. But yeah....not much choice.

In 3 fights this year he has won the WBO,IBF AND RING TITLE,thats 3 titles in 3 consecutive fights.And he had dominated in all fights scoring ko's in 2 and a huge knockdown in 1...this guy is phenomenal and the king at 122 Danny Garcia for me. Although ward or Nonito isn't a bad choice. If nonito beats arce in December by KO (more like when he does) he may move to the top of the list.

based on beating Khan(good win) and a shot to sh1t Morales? I agree Donaire should be FOTY but I wouldn't be dismissive of Garcia. Just based on titles, he won the WBC, WBA (regular), WBA (super), and Ring Magazine belt in TWO fights. Probably even has two candidates for KO of the year.

Macklin and Chavez Jr. are two pretty good wins for Martinez this year. Macklin + Chavez Jr. > Mathebula, WV2, Nishioka. Hands down. What a weak year if beating those guys makes you Fighter of the Year. SMH 2012!

If the Foch fight would have happened in Jan 2012 instead of Dec 2011, I would say Ward. But I'll agree with Donaire

Totally agree with Donaire.

no need to be butthurt about somebody having a different opinion than yours clown. fuk off. go catch a bus and jump in front of it.

I would agree Donaire wins it. Ward only fought once against Dawson. Martinez deserves mention for the Chavez and Macklin victories but Donaire deserves it.

hell no. Danny Garcia. when you caught a fade, did they bald fade your brain matter too? log off and never post again smdh.....

Yeah I think he has it wrapped up too.....

who Mentioned Ward?he only fougth 1 time because Ward is anther natural candidate

Macklin and Chavez Jr. are two pretty good wins for Martinez this year. That would be my first pick. Especially seeing how strong Macklin bounced back. I think thats going to be a win that will be overlooked now but will become more impressive over time.

Macklin and Chavez Jr. are two pretty good wins for Martinez this year. yeah and sergio dominated both guys so i wouldnt be mad if serg got it

based on beating Khan(good win) and a shot to sh1t Morales? vazquez and mathebula were impressive?

Macklin and Chavez Jr. are two pretty good wins for Martinez this year.

No Nishioka was #1 at 122..Morales has been irrelevant for YEARS!!!!!!!!!!!! I know morales is nothing. nishioka was #1 a year ago and came back from retirement to pick his check against nonito.

hell no. Danny Garcia. based on beating Khan(good win) and a shot to sh1t Morales?

Donaire/Arce has been canceled, Billy Dib vs Donaire is possible fight for December 15th go on his facebook Oh I didn't know that. Wasn't too excited for that matchup anyway.