Calzaghe, Froch, Hatton, and Hamed: How do you rank these resumes???

Joe Calzaghe 46-0 (32 KO's) 5 titles in 2 weight classes, 2x Lineal Champ (SMW and LHW) Chris Eubank (Top 10 SMW), Robin Reid (Top 10 SMW), Richie Woodhall (Top 10 SMW), Mario Veit, Charles Brewer (Top 10 SMW), Byron Mitchell (Top 10 SMW), Jeff Lacy (IBF SMW champ/#3 SMW), Sakio Bika, Mikkel Kessler (WBC/WBA SMW champ/#1 SMW), and Bernard Hopkins (RING LHW champ/#4 P4P). Carl Froch 29-2 (21 KO's) 3x SMW Champ Jean Pascal (Top 10 SMW), Jermain Taylor (Top 10 SMW), Andre Dirrell (Top 10 SMW), Arthur Abraham (Top 10 SMW), Glen Johnson (Top 10 SMW), and Lucian Bute (IBF SMW champ/#1 SMW). Ricky Hatton 45-2 (32 KO's) 4 titles in 2 weight classes, 1x Lineal Champ (JWW) Ben Tackie (Top 10 JWW), Kostya Tszyu (IBF/RING JWW champ/#3 P4P), Carlos Maussa (WBA JWW champ/#3 JWW), Luis Collazo (WBA WW champ/Top 10 WW), Juan Urango (IBF JWW champ/Top 10 JWW), Juan Lazcano (Top 10 JWW), and Paulie Malignaggi (#2 JWW). Naseem Hamed 36-1 (31 KO's) 3x FW champ, 1x Lineal Champ (FW) Steve Robinson (WBO FW champ/#3 FW), Manuel Medina (Top 10 FW), Tom Johnson (IBF FW champ/#1 FW), Kevin Kelley (Top 10 FW), Wilfredo Vazquez (#3 FW), Paul Ingle (Top 10 FW), Cesar Soto (WBC FW champ/Top 10 FW), Vyani Bungu (Top 10 FW). How do you rank these resumes????

Comments (20)

F_l_i_c_k_e_r

Froch Calzaghe Hatton Hamed

14y ago

Roy_Jones_Jnr

Calzaghe definitely has the best with the strength of his Hopkins and Kessler wins. I really don't feel much seperates Hatton and Froch. Even though Tszyu was older, he was still #3 P4P and unbeaten, that was a big big big win. And he has other solid wins on there as well. Froch, if he avenges the Kessler loss, would be ahead of Hatton in my book. Hamed is just a bit below Hatton and Froch, had some solid wins but no real big wins. If Bute doesn't go on to do anything, that win may end up like the Lacy win for Calzaghe. A good win, but not a great win or anything. Fair do's mate, your entitled to your opinion. I thought Hopkins beat Calzaghe so that's why i dont really count that but maybe im being unfair to him on that. I mean it was no robbery so maybe i should really credit him for that win.

14y ago

E2isME

I agree with 4corners Calzaghe Hatton Froch Hamed

14y ago

4Corners

Is that seriously your order????? Wow, i usually agree with most you say, but im shocked at this post haha, fair do's though mate, each to their own opinion. Calzaghe definitely has the best with the strength of his Hopkins and Kessler wins. I really don't feel much seperates Hatton and Froch. Even though Tszyu was older, he was still #3 P4P and unbeaten, that was a big big big win. And he has other solid wins on there as well. Froch, if he avenges the Kessler loss, would be ahead of Hatton in my book. Hamed is just a bit below Hatton and Froch, had some solid wins but no real big wins. If Bute doesn't go on to do anything, that win may end up like the Lacy win for Calzaghe. A good win, but not a great win or anything.

14y ago

New_England

there's a reason why you dont rank a fighter historically when he's in his prime and it's the day after a huge win.

14y ago

Roy_Jones_Jnr

Calzaghe, Hatton, Froch, Hamed. Is that seriously your order????? Wow, i usually agree with most you say, but im shocked at this post haha, fair do's though mate, each to their own opinion.

14y ago

Roy_Jones_Jnr

1. Froch. 2. Hamed. 3. Calzaghe. 4. Hatton.

14y ago

RockyB

1. Froch/Calzaghe 2. Hatton 3. Hamed

14y ago

Cardinal_Buck

1. Calzaghe 2. Froch 3. Naz 4. Hatton Froch has a ways to go before taking Calzaghe. @168 alone, not counting 175, he could catch him with a Kessler win and maybe one other respectable fighter.

14y ago

Jack_Napier

Froch Hamed Hatton Calzaghe Froch is kicking ass in a loaded division and only lost to the #1 guy don't think Kessler deserved the decision and fuck Dirrell, he fought so gay he deserved to be robbed Naz was the boss at 126 he mopped up all the belts and did so without losing WBA politics kept him from officially getting that belt no shame in losing to Marco Hatton had a decent run, but was never too impressed with him Kostya was on the way out when Hatton took him Maussa, Paulie, and Urango are ok wins no shame in the Pac loss, just dumb to try changing styles then fuck Calzaghe, he's a twat Hopkins fight was too ugly, boring, and indecisive for him to get props Roy was yrs shot by the time they fought Lacy and Kessler were good wins, Reid was a tough one Eubank was done

14y ago

Barry_Halls

Calzaghe greater than Froch when factoring the win over Hopkins for ring lhw title. At 168 it's close but i say Froch at 168.

14y ago

4Corners

Wow. Zoo was #3 p4p when Ricky beat him? Yes. He was #6 P4P and then his layoff happened. He dropped to #7 at the end of 2003. Than, Roy Jones lost and dropped off the Top 10 P4P. Mosley lost as well. And Oscar lost as well. Tszyu came back off his layoff and beat Sharmba Mitchell, who was the #1 JWW at the time, and Tszyu entered at #3 P4P again behind Mayweather and Hopkins.

14y ago

4Corners

Calzaghe, Hatton, Froch, Hamed.

14y ago

PrinceNaz88

1. Froch The other 3 don't have a massive amount to seperate them IMO.

14y ago

SOPH_REP

Froch -Highest level of opposition Hatton - Fought more in their prime Calzahge - Less respected 0 ever Hamed - Best entertainer

14y ago

DiegoFuego

Hatton's resume is the best of anyone on that list. He only lost to the two best fighters in the world. Calzaghe only has two meaningful wins: Kessler and Hopkins Froch's good wins are Abraham, Taylor and Bute. Froch clearly lost to Dirrell, and I scored it a draw against Pascal. Nothing legendary whatsoever there. Hamed was basically a fun show but was completely outclassed when he stepped up to the plate against Barrera.

14y ago

Biolink

Wow. Zoo was #3 p4p when Ricky beat him?

14y ago

Ryn0

I can't see Froch beating Hopkins so 1. Calzaghe 2. Froch 3. Hatton 4. Hamed

14y ago

NEETzsche

calzaghe > froch > hamed > hatton

14y ago

Optimistic

Froch Calzaghe Hatton hamed