Should Cotto and Margarito have a trilogy?

Hell No What's done is done no need for a third fight since let's be honest, can Margs eye handle anymore punishment? If Margarito fights on, all his opponets have to do is target that eye and then that's all she wrote. But it IS Top Rank............... oh well

Tony should retire hes not the same guy in terms of pressurizing fighters he was a few years back hes lost a step or two

Tony should retire for him and his wife's sake. Now all future fights against Margo can be won by aiming at his eye... and I'm not joking at that.

Absolutely not. Cotto has established who the better fighter is. Margarito should seriously consider retirement to protect his vision.

i think cotto leaving top rank and i can see arum throwing AM to chavez jr

Margarito should retire. That eye will close every time I gets hits. It will only get worse.

you got to be joking right? no need for it. margarito should fight mayorga while cotto fights chavez jr

miguel is no longer under contract with bob and may or may not sign with top rank again.. so it's not up to bob at this point. as for margarito.. his career might be over. he lost to mosley, pacquiao and cotto. because of this i don't see him another major fight anytime soon. there would be no incentive to fight him. I agree, I feel that Margarito has given the sport as much as he can. He may still be able to fight but not anywhere near the top. Either way i wish him the best if luck.

Should Cotto and Margarito have a trilogy? NO

I'm pretty content with this closure. It wasn't perfect but it will do. If there was a third i hope margarito gets paid accordingly. Not a lot.

miguel is no longer under contract with bob and may or may not sign with top rank again.. so it's not up to bob at this point. as for margarito.. his career might be over. he lost to mosley, pacquiao and cotto. because of this i don't see him another major fight anytime soon. there would be no incentive to fight him.

The question is...Will Bob Arum want it?

After that last one I'm good. I Doubt Cotto would want to reward Margarito with a paycheck again. Besides, Miguel obviously proved whom the more polished of the two was. Margarito is a waste of time and a walking punching bag.

Its over. Margo can fight Delvin Rodriguez or remtach Clottey or something.

I tried to make a poll but i guess i don't have a the privilege yet?

sure.... why not.

No Margarito doesn't deserve another crack at it,he didn't even deserve this one.

they are 1 a piece. and Margarito felt he could've kept going. what do you think? No... A plasterless Margarito proved tonight he couldn't compete with Cotto. Plus I don't think any state will sanction Margarito again based on his eye.

That's probable a realistic option for Arum

You should have made it a poll, Brahdah