Is Marquez more skilled than Margarito, Cotto & Clottey?

Absolutely.

Yes he is. And if he was as big and young as them, Pac would get stopped in 10 rounds. Clottey is the best one of those three BTW. Well, he's a lot better than them. I thought Clottey beat Cotto, and well I don't know if Plasterito really beat Clottey fair and square. No one knows if he beat any one pre Mosley fair and square.

Jmm is more skilled then all those fighters.... all those fighters beat him at ww though... funny how that works. good fight pac and roach :kiss:

who ever said no smfh

Won't matter. Marquez doesn't belong a pound over 140.

lol, didn't know it was another catchweight. Surprising to say the least. Another catchweight. Either way, Pacquiao will still come to fight 145-147. As he has done so in the past. So say he weighs in 144. Doesn't matter, he will fight 145. Pacquiao should have just made it a 140 fight. At least then it would be marginally legit. Unlike bringing a lightweight up to welterweight. LOL Flicker my friend... so wait. 147 was bad but 144 is a lower weight but it's worse because it's a catchweight. You just don't like Pacquiao. :lol1: :lol1: LOL Flicker I am laughing lol.. He weighs in a 144 but comes in at fight night 1 pound heavier............. Uh oh lol. I like you Flicker you are funny. This is more legit than the Floyd fight will ever be. His last fight was at 138. For the Floyd fight he had to blow up 12 pounds and Floyd cheated him on the scales by 2 pounds. Manny is not going to cheat Marquez.

Definetly. Cotto is the closest but none have the skill, craft, and adjustments of Dinamita.

In terms of skills, it goes: JMM Cotto Clottey Margarito Cotto/Clottey being interchangeable. But JMM gets abused by Manny worse than any of those guys at this point.

lol, didn't know it was another catchweight. Surprising to say the least. Another catchweight. Either way, Pacquiao will still come to fight 145-147. As he has done so in the past. So say he weighs in 144. Doesn't matter, he will fight 145. Pacquiao should have just made it a 140 fight. At least then it would be marginally legit. Unlike bringing a lightweight up to welterweight.

LOL are you there Flicker. ..

lol and you think Marquez isn't blowing up to reach 147? Pacquiao will come in 145 or 147. Marquez will come in 146 and look like a slob. It's not legit. Regardless. Fighting a lightweight at welterweight. Is not a legit fight. LOL.. .. ummm.... .... did you know the fight limit is 144? Wow lol.. http://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e373/saintelise/Funny/owned-cat.jpg

Marquez came in at 138 in his last fight and he can come in at 140 if he wants to since anything above 140 is WW. Pacquiao himself will probably come in at 143. This fight is legit. Floyds fight with Marquez now that was a disgrace. He made Marquez blow up 12 pounds, then cheated him on the scales by 2 pounds. :lol1: :lol1: lol and you think Marquez isn't blowing up to reach 147? Pacquiao will come in 145 or 147. Marquez will come in 146 and look like a slob. It's not legit. Regardless. Fighting a lightweight at welterweight. Is not a legit fight.

Marquez came in at 138 in his last fight and he can come in at 140 if he wants to since anything above 140 is WW. Pacquiao himself will probably come in at 143. This fight is legit. Floyds fight with Marquez now that was a disgrace. He made Marquez blow up 12 pounds, then cheated him on the scales by 2 pounds. :lol1: :lol1:

It's not legit because Marquez is fighting 2 weight classes above his most natural weight class.

So if Pacquiao is facing the most skilled he has faced in the past 3 years, how is this fight not legit? :lol1: :lol1:

one way too tell a boxing fan from a boxer's fan is.................any question involving clottey and top fighters It's a dead giveaway

Of course he's more skilled than all 3

Name me a fighter that is more skilled than Marquez period. Physically (speed, power, strength) yes there are better boxers but there aren't many out there that can throw combinations or adjust in a fight like Marquez does, it's beautiful to behold.

Skilled yes, but even then Marquez would lose to all 3 mentioned in the title at WW, so I'm not sure why point you trying to make here. I don't man I could see him beating Cotto at 144

you cansk if the skill set is better across the weights power is subjective though. I meant objective power. As it is as difficult a question.