if jmm beats manny and floyd beats ortiz.whos p4p#1 jmm,floyd or sergio

Marquez. I have Marquez at p4p #3 behind Floyd and Pacquiao, ahead of Martinez, and if things played out the way you say then Marquez gets the top spot for me. Nevermind, misread the question, thought it said if Ortiz beat Floyd. Obviously Floyd would move back to number one, if you don't already have him there.

floyd is still #1you need to beat the best to be the best manny or martines the two of then are the underdogs against floyd No...That's not how P4P works man. It's not a championship.

If Mayweather beats Ortiz and Pac loses to Marquez it will be Mayweather.

our living a fantasy boy. I see Pacquiao Ko over Marquez in 6 Ortiz shocks the world and beats or even Ko's Mayweather Cherry picken ass

floyd is still #1 you need to beat the best to be the best manny or martines the two of then are the underdogs against floyd You can't be #1 P4P if you fight 3 times in the last 4 years. Inactivity can get you off the list.

floyd is still #1 you need to beat the best to be the best manny or martines the two of then are the underdogs against floyd

Obviously, it depends on how the fights go. If Floyd wins but doesn't deserve it and Manny loses but got robbed, then neither should be considered the top dog. Under those circumstances, for example, my list would go something like this. 1. Sergio Martinez. 2. Floyd Mayweather. 3. Juan Manuel Marquez. 4. Manny Pacquiao. I would place it this way for a couple of reasons. Martinez has been on too much of a role to keep him seated at number two when Floyd isn't even ranked at this point due to inactivity and hasn't been fighting for prolonged periods. So, Martinez would be the top guy. After this point, you'd have to go with Floyd Mayweather simply due to his previous work and a decent win that would at least let you know he's boxing again. Whether or not he deserved the win wouldn't factor in much because he'd stil have his accomplishments and an undefeated record. He would be followed by Marquez who lost straight up and falls short just comparing skills. So, he'd be no higher than third and Manny would follow him due to the fact that the fight would have been questionable. That's just one example. It's very difficult to make a list like this, simply because we are dealing with the hypothetical and than trying to predict the future. Still, I'd imagine that in most circumstances, Martinez ends up heading the list.

id say JMM simply due to him beating the P4P. Ortiz isnt a P4P atleast yet!! Where does that put Ortiz if he pulls of an upset over Mayw? and after Martinez next opponent, he'll loose ground in the rankings. i can understand the first two i dont agree with jmm due to him beating p4p but i can understand it. but how can u penalize martinez because ever1 is scared to fight thats crazy to me you really think he cant beat everybody at his wieght.

Depends how Floyd looks against Ortiz and Marquez beats Pac. If they both beat their opponents in equally dominating or competitive fashion, I'd say JMM. If Floyd dominates Ortiz while JMM squeaks by Pac, I'd say Floyd.

Floyd would be #1. Even if he somehow beat Pac, JMM can't really be put above a guy who gave him a boxing lesson in a 12 rounds to 0 wipeout.

id say JMM simply due to him beating the P4P. Ortiz isnt a P4P atleast yet!! Where does that put Ortiz if he pulls of an upset over Mayw? and after Martinez next opponent, he'll loose ground in the rankings.

its gotta be sergio never seen so many people scared to fight somebody. then floyd he would be number 1 but right now sergio just looks like a monster right now then jmm he lost to floyd like it or not he lost

O why dont you tell us what you think Mr Monkey Excon

Probably Floyd....but if Manny beats JMM and Mayweather beats Ortiz, Manny will still be on top due to Floyd's long inactivity IMO

jmm man...is that even a question dumbo...