Out of curiosity, how would JMM have fared? Which would he win, which would he lose?
- Oscar De La Hoya
- Ricky Hatton
- Miguel Cotto
- Joshua Clottey
- Antonio Margarito
Poll to follow, Please discuss!
JMM would've iced Hatton and THAT 145 pound version of Hoya....but the big boys like Cotto, Clottey and Marg would've probably been too much for him IMO....Manny's SPEED killed ALL of them...JMM doesn't have that type of speed!! :boxing:
I think JMM would have beaten that version of DLH, Hatton, and Clottey.
Cotto and Marg beat him at 147, possibly by stoppage.
^^^^^^^^
I agree with this.
But I think Clottey has a good shot. I still lean towards Marquez though.
Out of curiosity, how would JMM have fared? Which would he win, which would he lose?
- Oscar De La Hoya
- Ricky Hatton
- Miguel Cotto
- Joshua Clottey
- Antonio Margarito
Poll to follow, Please discuss!
- Oscar De La Hoya - Odlh by UD
- Ricky Hatton - Marquez by KO
- Miguel Cotto - Cotto by KO
- Joshua Clottey - Clottey by KO
- Antonio Margarito - Margarito by KO
hatton beats that version of oscar hatton clotty and i think he beats cotto as well. marquez the better boxer and that cotto just didnt have that stalking intimidation body work. he was too wild and he backs off when hurt. that fight is a tossup. marquez vs margirito i dont know. i dont think margirito would hit marquez with as many shots he hit manny with btu i think the shots he do land would hurt. marquez would have to use his technique at its best. but margirito showed he was vulnarible to the body and manny didnt have the boxing iq to go there again. marquez could dig into his body and he is also good at pivots margirito size and chin is the only problem. but he sucks and hes slow and 1 dimensional
Out of curiosity, how would JMM have fared? Which would he win, which would he lose?
- Oscar De La Hoya
- Ricky Hatton
- Miguel Cotto
- Joshua Clottey
- Antonio Margarito
Poll to follow, Please discuss!
loses to Oscar by KO
beats Hatton by UD
loses to Cotto by KO
loses to Clottey by UD
loses to Tony by KO
LMAO!!!
BoxingTech718, Dick Gore, Flawless*, Gino Ros, HUITZILOPOCHTLI, KILLA RIGHT, mrcupide2, tacuso, TopVillain
Do you know these guys? These are the ones who voted that Marquez beats them all!!! http://www.emoticons4u.com/happy/671.gif http://www.emoticons4u.com/happy/671.gif
He beats them all comfortably,
The JMM that fought Floyd was the best JMM ever and showed enough to understand he would totally outclass opponents named
Clown flomo! Alright, JMM beat them all but Floyd already beat JMM so Floyd the greatest them all right? Why not say it directly and don't be shy! Floyd beat them without even need to fight Cotto, Clottey and Margarito right?
The posters who voted 5-0 should have their accounts deleted if they are serious.
Delahoya=zombie
Anyone beats him that night.
Hatton=sucks
Cotto=rendered weak and useless at 145
Clottey=would've let JMM just tee off on him at will
Margarito=way past prime and too slow for JMM
See how that works?
The posters who voted 5-0 should have their accounts deleted if they are serious.
nah, i doubt they are serious homeboy!.....nobody is really that stupid!...lol
He easily decisions or stops a 147' pound Oscar.
He easily k.o's Hatton.
He easily outboxes and maybe stops Cotto.
He decisions Clottey.
He decisions Margarito.
What's your point Woodside. These werent' hard fights given the catchweights and age of some of the fighters and the style of Clottey.
Maybe Hatton.
Even zombie dela Hoya would have ranged a slower JMM with jabs.
JMM likely wasn't winning a decision, and DLH certainly wasn't getting knocked out.. Starting to lean towards a DLH win.
Out of curiosity, how would JMM have fared? Which would he win, which would he lose?
- Oscar De La Hoya
- Ricky Hatton
- Miguel Cotto
- Joshua Clottey
- Antonio Margarito
Poll to follow, Please discuss!
dlh - jmm wins, but it's a very very dangerous fight for him. let's face it, dlh was an idiot to not rehydrate to 160+ lbs. but I don't see how that's pac's fault. jmm probably beats dlh if he can avoid getting hit with a big left hook and going down under the first 5 rounds. if it goes lates, it's possible jmm stops him.
hatton - jmm wins. same fight as the diaz and katsidis fights. jmm goes down early, rallies to win late when hatton gases.
cotto - jmm loses. cotto is just too big. jmm always goes down early. let's face facts. cotto sux against pressure fighters. jmm won't be able to pressure cotto or impose his size on cotto. also cotto hits way too hard. cotto wins by KO or decision.
clottey - jmm loses. clottey is just too big. even jmm won't be able to break down clottey, I doubt wifebeater could either. jmm willingness to trade will make him a target for clottey right hands and uppercuts. clottey has beaten everyone that he's fought from the lower weight divisions: judah, corrales, etc.... jmm could try and outwork clottey, but jmm is kinda flat footed now and would get hit with big shots. very dangerous for jmm, but not as dangerous as cotto or margarito.
margarito - jmm loses. margarito is just too big. jmm fights at 145 lbs... margarito comes in at 165 lbs. jmm gets pulverized and stopped.
some of you guys are delusion. there's a reason jmm went back to lightweight! it's because he can't hang at WW.
You have to have great footwork to be a good counter puncher dumbass! How the hell else do you make people miss and counter there ass with lead fuking feet?
umm no you don't. Watch james toney he stands flat footed but is one of the best counter punchers in this era. JMM is a very smart fighter but he simply doesn't have the footspeed to stay away from margarito, cotto or clottey.
You have to have great footwork to be a good counter puncher dumbass! How the hell else do you make people miss and counter there ass with lead fuking feet?
GTFO! counter punching is not great skills. i was talking about great skills u dumbass! its a skill yeah but not GREAT! great skills are not just counter punching. Manny has one of the best footwork, can counter punch, has power in both hands and the best hand speed combo and the best OFFENSE. thats what GREAT SKILLS im talking about.
Maybe hatton and even then marquez would go through hell. Marquez is a great a fighter but he doesn't have the footspeed and footwork of pac. He'd get walked down and bullied by all of them except maybe hatton.
Thats why styles make fights! Yes Manny is special because he has beat these gigantic fuking welterweights but what makes Marquez so special is that he can counter all that athletic ability.
What's your official vote out of curiosity?
Thats why styles make fights! Yes Manny is special because he has beat these gigantic fuking welterweights but what makes Marquez so special is that he can counter all that athletic ability.
And what makes NSB special is the posters who voted 5-0.