If Froch Won The Super 6 And Remained Undefeated, Would He Be A Greater SM than Joe

If he beat everyone in the Super6, no question. No one in the UK would recognise it though as theyn are all fooled by the 0,the record years as title holder and wins over RJJ and Bhop. Not a fan of Frochs personally though.

yes he would

Yes...Joe would have never faced these guys in the tournament at any point in his career. Defenses are good but who they are against should be taken in consideration.

I'd say yes in terms of over all comp, but Calzaghe faced some guys that would beat Froch IMO. I also feel Calzaghe would have beaten Forch also. I can't see Fprch winning more than 6 rounds and I also can't see Calzaghe getting KTFO by Froch who is very slow.

No. And he won't win anyway, unless the judges decide to give him a gift in every single fight. this tournament would be really fun if sven ottke was in it.

yes he would be greater than joe if he actually won the super 6 undefeated, but i don't think he will. I couln't really judge the dirrell fight with honesty cause i though dirrell was a totally pussy and the fight was just a stinkout where both looked shit, but dirrell made the fight go that way so since he did that and i paid for it twice to watch that shit, i allow froch that one. Calzaghe also has a couple or really close fights where some thought he lost, mainly reid and hopkins.

No. And he won't win anyway, unless the judges decide to give him a gift in every single fight.

Whoever wins this tourney has a better resume then Joe.

Crotch already lost to Dirrell. I just know Joe is more skilled

if he won that wit a couple KO's and a clear win against dirrell, then yes i'd consider him above Calz, even tho his chances of this are quite slim IMO

In my opinion yes he would, going by the oposition that both guys would have faced yes definatley froch would be greater than JC.

Well he beat Taylor, he "beat" Dirrell, he would have to beat Kessler, beat Arthur Abraham, after that its the semis I think right? But yes, imo he would be a greater 168 lber What are Taylor's credentials at 168? Shot Lacy? The same Lacy shot Roy destroyed?

calz never fought anyone half as good as all the peeps in the super 6

If he got through the entire Super6 undefeated then yeah, he'd be greater than Joe quite easily tbh. That level of competition, consistently, on opponents home-turf, at this stage in his career, trumps Joes "0".

Crotch already lost to Dirrell. a rematch with dirrel after super 6 should be lined up if dirrel doesnt get knockedout in the process

Crotch already lost to Dirrell.

Well he's off to a bad start. Most people thought he lost to Dirrell.