if cotto wins should/would he be fighter of the year?

The winner is probably the fighter of the year. Vitali can make a case too.

He'd probably get the nod.

Miguel, no Manny, yes Miguel is the bigger man and Manny is moving up to fight him. Miguel winning is not as significant as Manny beating the Welterweight Champ. i think this win would be very significant. cottos the underdog so imo cotto would and should win fighter of the year ... i cant really think of anyone else tbh that has done more this year to deserve it, i could be forgetting someone tho. who do u think should win if not cotto?

yes sir111111111111

Miguel, no Manny, yes Miguel is the bigger man and Manny is moving up to fight him. Miguel winning is not as significant as Manny beating the Welterweight Champ.

Nope. He hasnt been impresive in quite some time.

Only if he really wins unlike he did against Clottey and Mosley. http://i33.tinypic.com/2jczjt2.gif

Only if he really wins unlike he did against Clottey and Mosley.

Yes. He will and he should.

Yes. And Pac Man fighter of the Decade.

Either him or Vitali.

whoever wins that fight will probably get fighter of the year