140lbs Tourney - The Great Ones

The Arguello who fought Pryor would get dominated and stopped by Cotto and in alot quicker time.Arguello was clearly past it at that point and was very small for a junior welterweight,he isn't knocking out a man who outweighs him by twenty pounds.My point still stands,Pryor never beat a top fighter who wasn't clearly past it. Who do you have winning between Cotto and Pryor at 140, just curious?

The Arguello who fought Pryor would get dominated and stopped by Cotto and in alot quicker time.Arguello was clearly past it at that point and was very small for a junior welterweight,he isn't knocking out a man who outweighs him by twenty pounds.My point still stands,Pryor never beat a top fighter who wasn't clearly past it. You're an idiot. If Ricardo Torres, who BTW came into the fight on short notice, could bat Cotto around the ring, then Arguello would've damn near murdered him, and yes at 140lbs. And in a Jr Welter fight, Cotto wouldn't be coming into the ring at 160lbs. Face it Aaron Pryor will always be ranked above Miguel Cotto at 140lbs, if you can't see that, there's no hope for u.

ODLH Pryor Man why did you have to have that one? Pac Whitaker

Would Oscar outbox Taylor? Would Chavez win an inside war against Pryor? Would Kostya vs Manny make it to the final bell? Would Sweatpea box circles around Floyd?

Would Sweatpea box circles around Floyd?

Miguel Cotto actually beat top level opponents in their prime.Take away Pryor's wins over faded Antonio Cervantes and Alexis Arguello and you have absolutely nothing,or would you care to point out any other notable wins of Aaron Pryor's? The Arguello that fought Pryor in the first fight would have KTFO Cotto, bad.

but overall? Oscar beats everyone there (Prime). Not a prime Chavez. Chavez had too many miles on him by the time Oscar fought him.

id pick tszyu

He had a good run against limited opposition. He beat a past his prime Kostya. But he's not an ATG IMO. He must have done something right cause Pacquiao's only win at 140 was against Hatton and now Pacquiao's in the ATG 140 tourney?

Hatton did. And u know what happened to Hatton vs Pac. The old triangle theory. Get out!

Whitaker wins it.

but overall? Oscar beats everyone there (Prime).

He'd stop Pryor in 5. I'm sure he would :rolleyes:.

Oscar De La Hoya vs Meldrick Taylor (DLH UD) Julio Cesar Chavez vs Aaron Pryor (Pryor UD) Manny Pacquiao vs Kostya Tszyu (Pac TKO) Pernell Whitaker vs Floyd Mayweather (Whitaker SD)

Ricky Hatton is an ATG Light Welterweight! He had a good run against limited opposition. He beat a past his prime Kostya. But he's not an ATG IMO.

Ricky Hatton is an ATG Light Welterweight!

Whittaker-Mayweather would look like a break-dance competition in my opinion.

JCC wins the whole danm thing

people genuinely believe pac would beat tsyzu? delusional much?

Hatton reigned for 4 years!!! why isnt he in the list?