Would Cotto be P4P number 1?

I'd say he would jump to number 3.

not top 3. but 4-7. how come mosley is at 4 while Margarito was like 5 or 6 and cotto was like 5 or 6.

no way cotto ranks above bhop or mosley or the winner of pbf/jmm. mosley/cotto was a close fight and mosley destroyed margo while cotto quit against margo. that means cotto is #4 at best.

Definitely top 5. But not 1 yet. He needs another great win or two.

I'd say he'd probably go to #2 or 3.

He should be #2 or #3 if he wins in a very impressive manner. Marquez is most likely to lose, Pac losing would lose his spot, Hopkins is inactive and doesn't deserve to be current #3, Mosley is inactive plus he lost to Cotto and also doesn't deserve #4. impressive chicano right on point....if marquez somehow gets past jr it is gonna get real interesting. :boxing:

He should be #2 or #3 if he wins in a very impressive manner. Marquez is most likely to lose, Pac losing would lose his spot, Hopkins is inactive and doesn't deserve to be current #3, Mosley is inactive plus he lost to Cotto and also doesn't deserve #4. True. The p4p rankings are heading for a crazy shakeup this fall.

Top 3 easy. I wonder if Marg hadn't cheated and Cotto won would he be #1 P4P now. ........keep wondering

Top 3 easy. I wonder if Marg hadn't cheated and Cotto won would he be #1 P4P now. not top 3. but 4-7.

Top 3 easy. I wonder if Marg hadn't cheated and Cotto won would he be #1 P4P now.

he has to beat pac and then mayweather to be number 1

No he wouldn't. He jumps into the top 4 or 5 tho.