Is JMM the best fighter Floyd has ever fought?

Corrales and Castillo fought at the same weight, i don't know if JMM who will fight Floyd will be the same who fought at 135. I even believe Castillo would beat JMM

**** no. Jose Luis Castillo in his prime WAS. He beat mayweather the first time.

Yes. I think JMM is the best fighter. But Floyd has a significant weight advantage.

As far as skill and talent, I would say so. It's just tough to know how Marquez will handle the jump in weight.

JMM or Genaro Hernandez are the best to fighters Floyd will have fought

The Highest rated P4P he's fought before was Castillo. JMM's a much better fighter than Castillo.

P4P........yeah easily the best Floyd has fought. This wouldve been some fight if both guys were at 130/135 at the same time. Yeah I agree. Floyd had a little more offense in those days. Would have been a great fight.

P4P........yeah easily the best Floyd has fought. This wouldve been some fight if both guys were at 130/135 at the same time.

Absolutly Best calibre of a fighter he's ever faced.

Sweet Pea would have beat him, Meldrick Taylor would have also probably beat him. Don't think Meldrick Taylor would have beat him, Pernell Whitaker could have.

Most skillful? Yes Best fighter? No Who's the best fighter he's fought in your opinion?

P4P, its not even close JMM is the best he has ever fought. Unfortunately the move up to 144 or whatever this fight will be at will rob Marquez of the physical tools he would need to beat Mayweather. I believe that will be the case.

The most skilled, yes. P4P, it still wouldn't be Floyd's hardest opponent, Mayweather is all wrong for him. Marquez has a great offense, great counter puncher but his defense is lacking. Don't think I'll ever, besides possibly Pacquiao, see an opponent give Mayweather a harder time then JLC. Sweet Pea would have beat him, Meldrick Taylor would have also probably beat him.

voted yes :cool2:

P4P, its not even close JMM is the best he has ever fought. Unfortunately the move up to 144 or whatever this fight will be at will rob Marquez of the physical tools he would need to beat Mayweather. Cosign homey.

Not the toughest fight(obviously because of the size advantage). But the best fighter pound for pound and skill wise. I believe JMM is just that. Who do you think is? Most skillful? Yes Best fighter? No

Yes, if they were both the same size naturally it would have been a 50-50 fight, but it is a cherrypick and Floyd should win.

P4P, its not even close JMM is the best he has ever fought. Unfortunately the move up to 144 or whatever this fight will be at will rob Marquez of the physical tools he would need to beat Mayweather.

Skillwise? Absolutely. Marquez's skill and talent is sick.

Yeah, I believe so.