I'd say Cotto because he has fought all the top welters and most boxing analysts and experts are picking Pacquiao to win, plus Pac is #1 P4P. Mayweather on the other hand is the heavy favorite to win against JMM and his level of competition the last couple years has been questionable .
i thought p4p means a fighter that can fight in multiple weight class?
is a limited fighter who cant fight anymore below 145 and dont fight at 154 can be called a top 5 p4p? if cotto fights a bigger man, he can get high p4p rankings, but fighting a midget will not get him that status.
mayweather already proves that he can fight in 130-154 so he will be higher in p4p to cotto and floyd will reclaim #1. pac will still be #2 and jmm #3. cotto would be #5 or #6. a giant Fighting a midget is not how you get high p4p rank.
I'd say Cotto because he has fought all the top welters and most boxing analysts and experts are picking Pacquiao to win, plus Pac is #1 P4P. Mayweather on the other hand is the heavy favorite to win against JMM and his level of competition the last couple years has been questionable .
Cotto, until he fights PBF and looses...
I would say Cotto because he has fought everyone but Floyd probably will be ranked higher. Anyways I want to see Cotto- Mayweather after this so that would make things clearer.