So this SMW tournement...

Joe has Jones and Hopkins on the resume. Those 2 big names out ranks what ever opposition those other fighters have had combined. I'm not even a big Calzaghe fan and I can say that one. Except Taylor has Hopkins x2 on his resume, and I'm sorry but a W over an old Jones doesn't mean shit... hypothetically if Taylor were to beat Kessler he would have matched Joe's best wins... toss Lacy in there as well.

There are MANY fighters with better resumes then Joke Calzaghe. paul williams NOT being one of them. guess he is even more of a joke. :peeright:

zags was 36 himself when he fought jones and bhop (who then beat the tar out of a prime Pavlik in his next fight by the way) Jones is still faster than 95% of anyone that he will ever fight. great point thay were both past there prime win thay fought.but like i said calzage wanted this fight years earlyer and was turened down.:boxing:

zags was 36 himself when he fought jones and bhop (who then beat the tar out of a prime Pavlik in his next fight by the way) Jones is still faster than 95% of anyone that he will ever fight.

Yea we know how triangle theories work. Margarito beat Cotto and cotto beat mosley, therefore Margarito beats mosley.... ohh wait. Calz is a bitch, waits till b-hops is 44 to almost lose to him, and waits till roy jones is as fast valuev to fight him. fact is young man calzage tried to fight roy years earlyer and roy wanted no part of it.:boxing:

Yea we know how triangle theories work. Margarito beat Cotto and cotto beat mosley, therefore Margarito beats mosley.... ohh wait. Calz is a bitch, waits till b-hops is 44 to almost lose to him, and waits till roy jones is as fast valuev to fight him.

There are MANY fighters with better resumes then Joke Calzaghe. Joe has Jones and Hopkins on the resume. Those 2 big names out ranks what ever opposition those other fighters have had combined. I'm not even a big Calzaghe fan and I can say that one.

Calzaghe could come out of retirement and still win this thing and then retire again just to rub his greatness in the haters' faces. great point i agree.:boxing:

The winner of this tourney will have to be atleast p4p number 5 AT LEAST!!! The winner will also have a better resume than Calzaghe? Yes no discuss. I like either Taylor or Kessler in this thing. kessler wins easy and calzage beat him easy so your point is mote.:boxing:

Dude, had kesslers right hand not been broken, he would have beaten calzaghes ass

Calzaghe could come out of retirement and still win this thing and then retire again just to rub his greatness in the haters' faces.

taylor might not be the most likely person to do it but i'd be rooting for him to do it. Taylor is the best fighter who cant get over the hill and get the win. two losses to pavlik (both were winnable fights) the first fight he almost had him gone in the second round but go too excited and punched himself out without putting his punches where they need to go. and the froch loss was another close one. on my card he would have won if he hadnt gotten knocked down and ultimately stopped in the last round of their fight. so those are really tough losses to swallow. if he would have put pavlik away in the second round of the first fight he would have been the king of middleweight and probably avoided a rematch altogether (because if you remember correctly many were calling pavlik taylor's best possible opponent and taylor was making pavlik look real bad up until he punched himself out after dropping pavlik in the second round. a good clean shot landed by taylor would have put pavlik away due to how hurt he was after the KD). just my opinion. he's very skilled and born with great boxing talent. he just needs the right trainer and disciple to bring it out. taylor on his best night wins it.

kessler will take it calzaghes stock goes up ...the haters hate on ..

I imagine the winner would get a top 10 spot on the list.

If Taylor won it (dont think he will) and beats Kessler in the process he'd have a great shout at saying he had a better resume. then'd he share 3 of Joes best wins, Kessler + Hopkins + Lacy Yep top 5 at least i agree