where would you place pac in the atg list?

he'll be on the list. what number on the ATG list? how the hell should i know? i hear people say top 10 , top 25 , top 50 , top 100...... if you're gonna pull a top 40 remark out of your ass. please list the 40. in order. thanks. it's hard enough making a list of who you think is the top 50 or 100 fighters of all time. let alone trying to rank them accordingly. GOOD , GREAT , ALL-TIME GREAT. all the rankings i need. no need to number it. So watcha sayin?:werd:

if for some strange reasons he fights pbf, ssm and cotto in succession and beat them all. i'd probably put him top5 ATG just behind robinson, ali, armstrong and louis. If he beats PBF, SSM and Cotto in succession, he should surpass Armstrong and be ATG 1-2.

probably in the 30's... If marquez beats mayweather i would have him above manny in the all time great list. just for the fact that beating the undefeated Mayweather jr., juan diaz, and the lineal lightweight champ Casamayor is way better than beating the one dimensional hatton, and old dried out De la hoya, and the weakest light weight David Diaz.

So you wouldn't move him up at all? WOW. Read the thread wrong, I meant currently. if he did all that he would be at least top 20.

Somewhere in the 40's.... So you wouldn't move him up at all? WOW.

if that happens we are witnessing "All Time Greatness"!!!

Just outside the top 10..

thats a big if.. currently i have him between 35-50. but thats just my opinion

Somewhere in the 40's....

you may put him if he retires.