Who's the better FIGHTER? Pacquiao or Mayweather?

I think Floyd beats Manny at 147 because he's the bigger man. Yes they're similar in size but Floyd is bigger. Manny Pacquiao is the better fighter His Defense and Ring Generalship is under rated. His Power and Speed are arguably the best in the business poud for pound. Very good post. Manny is better overall. And that's the key word: OVERALL If they ever fought, and Floyd won, it's because he's clearly the significantly larger man. But Manny would always be the better man. Larry Merchant said it, the truth has been spoken.

when pac fights and wins its very exciting!!!! when pbf fights and wins its very boring!!! thats the difference!!

I think Floyd beats Manny at 147 because he's the bigger man. Yes they're similar in size but Floyd is bigger. Manny Pacquiao is the better fighter His Defense and Ring Generalship is under rated. His Power and Speed are arguably the best in the business poud for pound.

takes a "real warrior spirit" to fight a zombie oscar at 147 and david diaz at 135, and a shot ricky hatton at 140. if pac had a real warriors spirit he would have faced nate campbell at 135 the strongest champ instead of the weakest in david diaz. floyd went straigfht from 130 into the lions den at 135 with castilo why didn't pac do the same with campbell:dunno: Ricky Hatton's shot now? 135 was Floyd's second weight class, after a long run at 130. 135 was Manny's 7th if you count the one's he skipped and not before he won a title. Lol how Floyd went straight into the lion's den with Gatti (instead of Tszyu or Cotto.)

nope, he was right the first time. hence why you dont know shit. here, suck on your :bottle: sucky baby Did I just offend 5*'s biatch? Who are you, his wife?

pac is the better fighter. floyd is the better boxer. why can't ignorant mofos compromise???

Anyone who says Manny is better then Floyd doesnt know boxing period. Anyone who says "Anyone who says Manny is better then Floyd doesnt know boxing period" don't know shit. Period.

I guess Larry Merchant don't know shit then.pretty much...he is biased towards manny and has been for a long time...i guarantee you, he wouldn't say if floyd and manny were face to face, that manny pac is the bretter fighter...i gurantee you...larry himself said floyd fights as naturally as a fish swims...so, basically, he thinks with his heart as do you and many other heart thinkers on this forum do...bixing is made dramatic by heart...boxing matches are won by smart thinking...no fighetr i this era or the last era is a smarter fighter than floyd jr, period...he is the better fighter, no contest...

Anyone who says Manny is better then Floyd doesnt know boxing period. I guess Larry Merchant don't know shit then.

what's that based on? Floyd is not Zab Judah... ...and Floyd is not Manny Pacquiao.

what's that based on? Floyd is not Zab Judah... based on: - morales 3x - mab 2x - jmm 2x - dlh 2 divisions above his current weight at the time (pac was a heavy underdog) - hatton who is a bigger guy at 140 (pac destroyed hatton in 2) - moving up from 106 lbs to fight at 147 lbs - 6 titles in 6 weight divisions - 4 lineal divison titles - willingness to fight cotto - willingness to fight margarito - willingness to fight mosley - etc...

Pacquiao is winning the poll, I'm not surprised :D lol you should love this thread: http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=268048

heart and warrior spirit... Manny Pacqiuao by a country mile what's that based on? Floyd is not Zab Judah...

At the end of the day most polls end up with biased results. They are polar opposites. Pacquiao attributed to aggression Mayweather attributed to tactician

Skill wise.. Floyd Mayweather by a country mile.. heart and warrior spirit... Manny Pacqiuao by a country mile

pac's the better fighter, floyd is the better boxer agreed On this subject, Pacquiao ain't on Floyd's level but it don't matter. Pacquiao gonna win the poll anyway, you can't involve Pacquiao fans in any poll...NO OFFENSE, but most are stupid. just like floyd fans but not so bad

Pacquiao is the better fighter Mayweather is the better boxer

Who is the better all around fighter? Consider the 4 elements of judging boxing rounds. Clean Effective Punching Effective Aggression Ring Generalship Defense Skill wise.. Floyd Mayweather by a country mile..

So it appears that even Merchant thinks Manny is better. Larry has spoken, the debate is over. This, Merchant believes, is what made him pick Pacquiao as the better man. “If you look back at the record, though, I think it shows that Pacquiao is better. I want someone willing to take risks, someone who moves me,” he said. “I think Pacquiao is better than Mayweather.”

They are both equal.