ATG Status: Manny - No Doubt; Floyd - Self-Proclaimed

Floyd has ATG skills but has not had an ATG great career yet. His resume pales in comparison to srl, hearns, hagler, duran, oscar, pac and nard Best post I've seen so far.

both are great, but pac's resume looks better

Floyd has ATG skills but has not had an ATG great career yet. His resume pales in comparison to srl, hearns, hagler, duran, oscar, pac and nard

They are both ATG's, but Pac is ahead due to a much superior resume and considering he started at Flyweight and has fought as high as Welterweight. Winning 4 linear championships on his way. Mayweather is obviously more skillfull boxer, but when you talk about ATG status that counts for less if you haven't fought anyone of note. By the way i like both fighters, so don't call me a hater that's just my opinion on both fighters.

They are both ATG's, but Pac is ahead due to a much superior resume and considering he started at Flyweight and has fought as high as Welterweight. Winning 4 linear championships on his way. Mayweather is obviously more skillfull boxer, but when you talk about ATG status that counts for less if you haven't fought anyone of note. By the way i like both fighters, so don't call me a hater that's just my opinion on both fighters.

It's hard to argue that Mayweather isn't an ATG. I just wish he'd done more in his career. He's an ATG in skills, but it pretty much ends there. So many awesome fghts, so many great possible matchups, very little materialized relative to what could have been. That is why I will always hate Floyd.

The only ATG between them 2 is Mayweather, simple. May not be the best entertainer, but skill wise, He's 100x years ahead of Manny. Stop your hating and start you loving because the king is Back...

Love him or hate him FMJ is an ATG, not debatable really. I'd say it's debatable. He's the only one talking about his ATGness and you all fools listen to his broke ass. Manny's resume is stellar and a resume of an ATG fighter. Floyd's is questionable. And in the case of their two most recent common opponents (lets not forget that Manny started his career as a Flyweight), Manny's performances overshadow Floyds why? He made Oscar quit and almost decapitated Ricky Hatton with a single shot. It can be argued that Oscar beat Floyd and it took Floyd (the larger man) 10 scardy cat, defensive rounds to finally get Ricky out of there.

Hahaha self proclaimed mayweather is in top 150 or lower More like top 50 and higher:twak:

3 Pac dickriders in one thread...wat a suprise...

For years, Floyd has been his own biggest cheerleader about his status as an ATG fighter. The media talks more about Floyd TALKING about his greatness than they do actually covering how great he really is. Then you got Manny Pacquiao. A humble and reserved type fellow who respects his opponents and doesn't talk any shit. Manny does his talking with his fists. And now, there is NO question as to whether or not Manny is an All Time Great fighter. He's sealed the deal; everything else is icing on the cake. Just thought is was kinda funny how Floyd has been trying for years to convince everyone that he's an ATG fighter, while Manny just performs and lets the experts and media do that for him. Hey listen, I see where u gettin at here. But I think its just 2 different personalities. Dont get it twisted though, Floyd is an ATG.

For years, Floyd has been his own biggest cheerleader about his status as an ATG fighter. The media talks more about Floyd TALKING about his greatness than they do actually covering how great he really is. Then you got Manny Pacquiao. A humble and reserved type fellow who respects his opponents and doesn't talk any shit. Manny does his talking with his fists. And now, there is NO question as to whether or not Manny is an All Time Great fighter. He's sealed the deal; everything else is icing on the cake. Just thought is was kinda funny how Floyd has been trying for years to convince everyone that he's an ATG fighter, while Manny just performs and lets the experts and media do that for him. Agreed :op:

Both are ATG, Pac is simply higher than Mr boat buyer.

I'm not going to argue Manny is a better ATG at the moment and probably will end up that way. His body of work is amazing, he's exciting, he's constantly fought the best & he's got an amazing connection with the people. His charisma is unparalled in boxing today. The 6 titles in 6 weight classes & 4 lineal titles doesn't hurt either.

Love him or hate him FMJ is an ATG, not debatable really. ^^ This Mayweather might proclaim his greatness first and foremost, but you wont find anybody who's not a complete retard who disagrees.

For years, Floyd has been his own biggest cheerleader about his status as an ATG fighter. The media talks more about Floyd TALKING about his greatness than they do actually covering how great he really is. Then you got Manny Pacquiao. A humble and reserved type fellow who respects his opponents and doesn't talk any shit. Manny does his talking with his fists. And now, there is NO question as to whether or not Manny is an All Time Great fighter. He's sealed the deal; everything else is icing on the cake. Just thought is was kinda funny how Floyd has been trying for years to convince everyone that he's an ATG fighter, while Manny just performs and lets the experts and media do that for him. Love him or hate him FMJ is an ATG, not debatable really.

O really?............