who are your top 10 welterweights at the moment. welterweight and light welterweight. your list doesnt have to be in order because i might upset you:)
This is what the thread starter said^^^147 &140
Mosley
Cotto
Clottey
Berto
Williams is not a welterweight and he is not even above Cotto.
Paul williams can easily make the weight and if any of the big names would accept an offer to fight him at WW, Paul would be there in a heart beat. Its a difference between outgrowing a weight class and just moving up to fight a big time fight.
first paul williams is not a welter any more. Pacman beat a man who wasnt even ranked top 20 in welterweight no more mayweather is retired and hasnt fought in over a year now ricky hatton had 2 fights at welter one was a contrevercial decision and the other he got kocked out in and jmm and vic ortiz never fought at 147
Mayweather is gonna fight this is comon knowledge. Again Im just looking at it as if this was like it was in the 60s when welterweight was 147 and 140. If these fighters all fought round robin then this is the order I believe it will finish at. I dont see any welterweight beating paul williams at the stage he is at right now.I think pac can descision any welterweight right now and while ortiz is still green he can beat majority of the guys just like JMM. All of this is hypothetical because I really believe none of the big names will clash anytime soon anyways.
Victor Ortiz and Juan Manual Marquez have not even had a fight at welterweight (147)? You can't rank Floyd because he has yet to come out of retirement and I wouldnt rank Pacquio or Hatton at 147 either because they havnt done anything at that weight class...
1. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Andre Berto
5. Luis Callazo
6. Carlos Quintana
7. Zab Judah
8. Issac Hlatswayo
Will not rank Margarito
He said welterweights as in 147 and 140 which is light welterweight. I based my list of if they fought each other who would win. I got paul williams beating everyone and marquez up ther because out side of hatton,pac and ortiz no one at 140 is touching him inside the ring.
-Mosley
-Cotto
-Clottey
-Berto
-Collazo
-Quintana
Cotto would have been #1 but Margarito beat him "yes its a tainted victory"
Then Mosley beat the man that beat the man so yea...
I put Berto above Collazo only because he has more natural talent and potential
but I still think Collazo gave him more than he could handle last outing.
Victor Ortiz and Juan Manual Marquez have not even had a fight at welterweight (147)? You can't rank Floyd because he has yet to come out of retirement and I wouldnt rank Pacquio or Hatton at 147 either because they havnt done anything at that weight class...
1. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Andre Berto
5. Luis Callazo
6. Carlos Quintana
7. Zab Judah
8. Issac Hlatswayo
Will not rank Margarito
you got skill not to rate a cheat, heres some karma
1 Paul Williams
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Miguel Cotto
4 Floyd Mayweather Jr.
5 Shane Mosley
6 Joshua Clottey
7 Ricky Hatton
8 Joshua Clottey
9 Juan Manuel Marquez
10 Victor Ortiz
And yes...that's my list in order.
Victor Ortiz and Juan Manual Marquez have not even had a fight at welterweight (147)? You can't rank Floyd because he has yet to come out of retirement and I wouldnt rank Pacquio or Hatton at 147 either because they havnt done anything at that weight class...
1. Shane Mosley
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Joshua Clottey
4. Andre Berto
5. Luis Callazo
6. Carlos Quintana
7. Zab Judah
8. Issac Hlatswayo
Will not rank Margarito
1 Paul Williams
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Miguel Cotto
4 Floyd Mayweather Jr.
5 Shane Mosley
6 Joshua Clottey
7 Ricky Hatton
8 Joshua Clottey
9 Juan Manuel Marquez
10 Victor Ortiz
And yes...that's my list in order.
Hell I'm in the red,don't know how I got there,or how to get out,but I hope u picked the Punisher on saturday and Cotto is better offensively and thats about it,Clottey has better defence and is more durable,plus the better counter puncher and probably the better jab too!!
yeah of course i chose williams, winky's older now
nah clottey keeps his hands up most of the time, hes gonna have to change and he hasnt got as much skill as cotto, would make a bet wit ya but i might loose points on saturday but i doubt it
Hell I'm in the red,don't know how I got there,or how to get out,but I hope u picked the Punisher on saturday and Cotto is better offensively and thats about it,Clottey has better defence and is more durable,plus the better counter puncher and probably the better jab too!!
Jennings is no Clottey and Clottey doesnt get hurt,if anyone gets in trouble it will be Cotto!!:rofl:
nah clottey keeps his hands up most of the time, hes gonna have to change and he hasnt got as much skill as cotto, would make a bet wit ya but i might loose points on saturday but i doubt it