gatti or tszyu

Kostya wins by 1st round KO. Not even a fight.

Tszyu would flatten Gatti and it would mean nothing

Beat most JWW and win a title , your dreaming mate , I hope he stays retired , KT will get embarrassed by the top JWW he is 40 yrs old and hasnt done a thing in 4 yrs and was well past his prime back then , he should stay retired . Yeah its been too long and hes too old, I dont want to see him back. He would have ****ed up gomez though

No point to this. KT would win.

kostya would have landed 6 right hands on gatti before he even enters the ring. Best. Post. Ever. Seriously though both guys should stay retired.

aint no shame in thats...he got ko'd by baldomir man..and retired by alfonzo fukkin gomez..now that embarrasing yeah boldomir the best welter that floyd beat. and gomez fair play he gave an old Gatti a beat down but at least Gomez had the balls to fight Cotto.

aint no shame in thats True, and Floyd did a classy number on him. But it was still devastating to watch, whereas Tszyu fought hard until the (near) end.

Tszyu would take him clean out with one dutty acurate shot But matchup would be pointless but fun to watch

If Tszyu still has the desire and skills, I would love to see him back. I never got to see much of him in his prime, so I'd be interested to see what he could do to the current crop of 140'ers (except Hatton, who would make him quit again). Gatti... just no. The way he got schooled by Floyd was devastation compared to the gutsy fight that Tszyu put up for 11 rounds against Hatton. um, tszyu should not fight active 140 lbers... he should stick to retired shot fighters like gatti

If Tszyu still has the desire and skills, I would love to see him back. I never got to see much of him in his prime, so I'd be interested to see what he could do to the current crop of 140'ers (except Hatton, who would make him quit again). Gatti... just no. The way he got schooled by Floyd was devastation compared to the gutsy fight that Tszyu put up for 11 rounds against Hatton.

theres talk about gatti coming back and kostya tszyu coming back. if they was to fight each other who would win? I'm going with tszyu. and where would that place them? I would not place them anywhere... both are retired and these retirement fights mean nothing.

Tszyu KO anytime he wants it really.

Tszyu would destroy Gatti if they fought each other! If Tszyu does come back I'd expect him to still be able to beat most JWW and probably win a title there again. Gatti may win a fight or 2 but he's totally shot and will never again compete anywhere near the top. Gatti needs to carefully select any potential opponent. Gatti really should stay retired!

kostya would have landed 6 right hands on gatti before he even enters the ring.