Does vic deserve to be placed in p4p top 10??

Yeah, after his loss to Donaire he has been fighting well and has been dominating top guys in the devision, he deserves to be on the list, around 8-10.

i think for now he deserve to be on the top 10 ... he had a great 2008 fought 3 fights all against world caliber/champ opponents and one p4per... and now started 2009 with a bang...

He did before this fight. Dominatin and stoppin 2 champions to unify his division shoulda got him in.

No, and Ivan Calderon should be #1.

I think he's borderline, but a win over montiel would clinch it

I personally think one more big win and for sure he'll in the top 10. how many top fighters do he have to beat handidly for him to be considered top 10. If you dont consider Vic a top ten P4P fighter then you do not know the fight game.

He has a solid argument for it, thats for sure. With Calzaghe retiring and Margarito getting sparked, we could have some crazy rankings for a little while.

I personally think one more big win and for sure he'll in the top 10.

The p4p is stacked... We have chris john fighting juarez and if he win, he could be a good candidate for p4p top ten....

Vic is easily in the top 10 had the Nonito fight not happened. Donaire's victory over him will always cast a black cloud on Vic. Vic has to either beat Donaire or Donaire loses his next fight against anyone (so Vic won't have to fight him again), then...Vic could be in the top 10.

I think he deserve it for now.. He beat mijares which was top one of the top ten...

If he were to fight and beat Donaire pretty handidly I could see him getting there. I just don't think he beats Donaire.