Which was the worse beatdown?

IMO, Mosley vs Margarito... Mosley outclassed him like Pacquiao outclassed De La Hoya, however Mosley Knocked Down Margarito which is saying something due to Margarito's very impressive chin, Mosley shown his speed and power. Not taking anything from Pacquiao's win though... they were both excellent fights!

First off Mosely is a much bigger puncher than Pac so its just natural that his punches are going to inflict more damage than Manny's...Oscar and Margarito both got their asses handed to them, but at the end of the night if I had to choose I would have rather been Oscar...Margarito was getting blasted by a legitimate 147 lb fighter with heavy hands who has been all the way up to 154 and fought effectively there... Margarito was stretched out and seperated from his senses...Oscar was totally frustrated and knew that there was no way he could overcome the speed and quickness of Pac... The biggest difference is that Oscar's fight was stopped to save him the embarrasment of being shutout and completely frustrated by a smaller fighter and huge underdog...Margarito's fight was stopped in order to save his life... :lol1: Real Talk!

First off Mosely is a much bigger puncher than Pac so its just natural that his punches are going to inflict more damage than Manny's...Oscar and Margarito both got their asses handed to them, but at the end of the night if I had to choose I would have rather been Oscar...Margarito was getting blasted by a legitimate 147 lb fighter with heavy hands who has been all the way up to 154 and fought effectively there... Margarito was stretched out and seperated from his senses...Oscar was totally frustrated and knew that there was no way he could overcome the speed and quickness of Pac... The biggest difference is that Oscar's fight was stopped to save him the embarrasment of being shutout and completely frustrated by a smaller fighter and huge underdog...Margarito's fight was stopped in order to save his life...

Manny vs Oscar? Or Mosley vs Margarito? losing to a former 106 lbers is more embarrassing

if u quit it makes it worse ...margarito is a true warrior and half insane because he did not wanna quit

Neither fight was close, but Mosley/Margarito was more competitive. Oscar just looked hopeless every second of that fight.

I agree, but at least Tony won one round.... and what round did tony win? it was a wash on my scorecard.

Mosley-Margarito. He hit him with some bombs, and put him on his ass twice. Margarito was out. De La Hoya was never really out like that. He was just beaten up. that sums it up. delahoya was beat up, margarito got raped.

clearly the latter

Mosley-Margarito. He hit him with some bombs, and put him on his ass twice. Margarito was out. De La Hoya was never really out like that. He was just beaten up.

Manny vs Oscar? Or Mosley vs Margarito? No comparison. Mosley landing devastating power punch after power punch throughout the fight and he knocked a grannit chinned fighter out.

Buenos Dias, damn, this shit is tied up. I surely thought Mosley - Margarito would be the choice here.

Manny vs Oscar? Or Mosley vs Margarito? Manny beat the shit out of Oscar was nasty....

pac/dlh wasnt a batdown, it was a little midget embarassing a shot fighter, i bet oscar is fine he wont have no serious damage.. margarito took some nasty punches, mosleys probably give him brain damage.

both got the post fight press conference beat outta them :lol1:......lets look at this closely......who hits harder? Pac or Shane?....I say Shane......Oscar went 7 rounds......Marg went 9........Oscar took 224 total punches with 195 of them being power punches....Margarito took 178 shots with 118 bein' power punches........Pac landed more shots in a shorter time but thats mainly because his opponent was a corpse.....he offered no resistant.....on the other hand Margarito came to fight :boxing: Shane did more damage to Margarito than Pac did to Oscar because......Margarito was swingin', opening up to get hit with hard flush shots.....Oscar didn't do shit but cover up. So Marg took the harder shots from the bigger stronger man!

I've got to go with Pac-DLH,because Oscar actually quit on his stool,I'm pretty sure Margarito would have continued,if they had let him!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you mean "if"? They did let him and he went back out and got knocked out 43 seconds into round nine. Someone didn't even watch the fight. I'm pretty sure Mosley/Marg was much worse. A guy that was in his prime and had just beaten down the undefeated 'future' of the welterweight division against a former star at 37 years of age coming off a lackluster performance who somehow managed to overcome the massive odds and simply annihilate someone who many considered to have one of the greatest chins of all time. He did it by breaking him down to the body and then the head over and over and over again. An old guy who just doesn't throw back and gets pounded on is bad, but Oscar never really looked hurt or like he was going to be knocked out. Margarito, the supposedly iron chinned, immovable, ultimate tough guy, was pounded every which way for every second of the fight. Whoever gave him that round, I think it was seven, only did so because it was a slower round for Mosley, not because Margarito actually won it. Just a comparison 'mercy' round for him. Mosley put a beat-down on Margarito that no one ever thought could be put on him and no one had ever even gotten close to. Oscar stopped in between rounds, which meant he could have gone on, and really, he probably could have made it to the final bell if he wanted to. Margarito was beaten so badly to the head and body that he had no choice in whether he wanted to stop or not. He got stopped, the decision was not his it was Mosley's. Therefore, Mosley put the bigger beat-down on Margarito.

he didn't get faster. cotto got slower.

De la Hoya's Pac-down was pretty gnarly, considering the size discrepency. Mosley busted Margarito up pretty good though. Margarito/Cotto was just ****ing nasty though. I've never seen so complete a victory; a fighter so obviously deflated - Cotto was pulverized physically and mentally. It must have been so demoralizing for Cotto, I'm surprised he lasted as long as he did. Cotto's got power, and he hit Margarito with Every. Single. Punch he had, again and again and again, cleanly, and from a solid stance. And it never even slowed Margarito down. He got faster and closer and more brutal as the fight wore on. What do you at that point, when you realize you have nothing to hurt the other man with, nothing to stop him from doing what he wants to you? I guess you take the inevitable, tidal wave-like beating until you just can't keep going. Ugh. Brutal brutal brutal.

oscar was getting his ass scraped...nd not answering back marg was at least giving some shots to mosley but just ended a little more dramatic...

To be fair you could make a case for any of the two. Margorito and Mosley: Mosley was the 4-1 underdog going into this title fight...Many have counted him out and Margorito just DESTROYED that man that beat shane in the past...Margorito was none for his "Iron Chin" going into this fight...Margorito had a very good trianing camp and came into the fight in good shape...He had the fresher legs of the two being 7 years younger than Mosley...Margoito was the taller and bigger fighter going into the fight 5'11 compared to 5'9...Shane beat him inside and outside and straight up DOMINATED Margorito. Despite all of the allegation on Margorito's hand wraps..He still beat the living shit out of him...That deserves a lot of credit!:boxing: Pacman vs DLH: Manny was truley above his head in this fight going into it...He had to overcome a big size differential...He is fighting 2 weight classes above his own division...and some had questions on how he was going to take the bigger man shots since he has never fought at WW...Oscar who was a past it, still could (at lest we thought he was going to fight back:rofl:) tried but failed badly:blackeye: Pacman displayed a thing of beauty in the ring against DLH. IMO I think its a draw...because you've got to admit when the fight was over...you looked at you T.V crazy:?!: (I know some of you guys were in shock) thinking to yourself like WHAT THE FUCK JUST HAPPENED?!?!?!