Cotto and Margarito both have exited. I understand #6 Mosley but not #10 Caballero. He's great fighter but Williams, Donaire, Darchinyan all could have argument for being there. Especially Paul who was #10 before his Phillips win.
Regardless of what DLH and Golden Boy says, I havent taken their list seriously since they've bought it. And imo it does show small signs of bias. When you get outside of the top 3-4, it gets very subjective.
When I argued for vic being top 10 I got shot down by 80% of this forum. Now, hoooowww da helll is caballero on there. Anyone who is in a divison with Rafael Marquez, Israel Vazquez, and Juanma Lopez and has yet to fight either should not even come up in conversations for top 10. BTW if PW deserved to be top 10 over Vic why da hell did he just drop out?
Caballero is an odd choice, but its a messed up p4p list as it is.
I'd like to hear their reasoning on having him above Williams, Darchinyan, and Donaire.
Ring magazine should let someone with an unbiased opinion of Golden Boy Promotions do there P4P b/c they always favor there fighters, and B-Hop is not a top 5 P4P anymore and if Shane is even on the list he is 10 in my eyes and 9 at best, SMH at Shane being higher then Cotto even though Cotto beat him and Cotto has only lost one fight, Shane has fought good lately but he ain't a top 8 P4P imo.
I dont think ive seen Caballero fight is he good? Well obviously if he makes the ring top 10 but whats hhe like?
The guy is pretty good 6ft tall fighting at 122
Caballero shouldnt be in there yet
If they are going to remove Caballero in there then they should also remove Rafael because he hasnt done anything lately aside losing against Izzy
The ring divisional rankings are very good, but their P4P list always sucks!!!!!!!!!!!
Even their divisional rankings sucks they have rafael marquez as no2 in the 122 division when he hasnt done anything in that division in the past 1 1/2 aside from losing to Izzy twice.
PW nor Caballero deserve to be there at this moment. I would put Vic up there instead of Cab.
yeah he knocked out Mijares who was P4P, and Donaire KO'd Vic
17y ago
Mosley and Caballero enter Ring P4P list | BoxingScene Community