Has Margarito become vastly overrated?

no not at all, Mosley has just been vastly underrated.

Where is that Sport writer who said margarito was top 5 best welterweight of all time..???? He needs to quit his job and be shot on sight!!!

I think ultimately the answer was an emphatic yes!!! Crazy to see Marg curling up on the ropes in retreat.

I think ultimately the answer was an emphatic yes!!! Crazy to see Marg curling up on the ropese in retreat.

I'll give him all the credit if he walks through Shane like some on here think.

How do you get over rated by continually beating quality opposition? Its not like hes fighting lower tier fighters and getting praise. Hes fighting the best of the division time after time. Well he already beat Cotto for one. Mosley, I just view as a good matchup for Margarito. Sure he needs to go in there and take care of business (and depending on what happeans it could be impressive). To me he should beat both guys, and if you should beat both guys what is truly impressive about that, other then taking care of your business (or the way in which it is done) and moving on to bigger and better things.

He is like all other fighters, overrated by some underrated by others. He is good, but he only has 1 speed and one way of doing things, eventually that will cost him against a better more versitile fighter that does not let him get off or just runs away and outboxes him since he is terrible at cutting off the ring. He is fun to watch though and has earned his place, I would also be pretty suprised if Margarito lost either of his next 2 fights (Mosley and Cotto rematch, if he does win those fights then yes he will probably be very overrated though I reckon). How do you get over rated by continually beating quality opposition? Its not like hes fighting lower tier fighters and getting praise. Hes fighting the best of the division time after time.

He is like all other fighters, overrated by some underrated by others. He is good, but he only has 1 speed and one way of doing things, eventually that will cost him against a better more versitile fighter that does not let him get off or just runs away and outboxes him since he is terrible at cutting off the ring. He is fun to watch though and has earned his place, I would also be pretty suprised if Margarito lost either of his next 2 fights (Mosley and Cotto rematch, if he does win those fights then yes he will probably be very overrated though I reckon).

I don't think he's overrated... but more than anything I just wanted to test out my signature

Those are stans though, not fans. I have no problem saying Margarito could potentially lose rematches against both Clottey and Williams. I just said the other day that Margarito won't be nothing much at 154. Some people just think a few nutty stans represent an entire segment of fans. Yeah i feel ya.. its the same way with some of the Mayweather Fans.. LOL not all us are lame!!

:bottle: This is for the babies who get mad at a valid statement. For some reason if someone questions Margarito they have to be a PBF fan. Wtf? Mayweather is cool but it has shit to do with Marg fans going overboard at times.

i dont hate him, i just dont like some of his gay fans... i think he's overrated by some of his gay fans just a tad.. thats not saying i think he's a bad fighter because he obviously is good Those are stans though, not fans. I have no problem saying Margarito could potentially lose rematches against both Clottey and Williams. I just said the other day that Margarito won't be nothing much at 154. Some people just think a few nutty stans represent an entire segment of fans.

yes he has been overrated but for good reason he beat alot of top ww's but his boxing ability isnt as good as cottos,moselys,or pbf. this is why cotto will be a better boxer than marg just not as good of a chin

He's the #1 ranked welterweight. Not overrated just hated by Mayweather fans. :lol1: i dont hate him, i just dont like some of his gay fans... i think he's overrated by some of his gay fans just a tad.. thats not saying i think he's a bad fighter because he obviously is good

No, Marg just has become vastly hated. Co-sign. Marg has never changed what he does. He's the same fighter he's always been, he's just had a chance to show it in a big fight. He got a lotta shine for the Cotto victory. And of course, PBF cocksuckers can't stand it, so they hate him wit a criminal passion nowadays.

Find me a thread where more then one Margarito fan will even admit that Marg even has a chance of losing and we can talk. It's just like the people on here who only follow Pacman fights. They think he is God and cant be stopped. Most posts are something like "Nobody can touch the Mulleted madness of the Tornado!!! He is the greatest and most feared fighter in the world! He would KO FLoyd! He will kill Mosley in the ring! I feel bad for Cotto cause Marg took his soul! Hate on haters but he is the best" and so on. They dont have to just say "He cant be beaten" but it is implied. oh, so you can't then. Ok, thanks for trying.

Find me a thread where more then one Margarito fan will even admit that Marg even has a chance of losing and we can talk. It's just like the people on here who only follow Pacman fights. They think he is God and cant be stopped. Most posts are something like "Nobody can touch the Mulleted madness of the Tornado!!! He is the greatest and most feared fighter in the world! He would KO FLoyd! He will kill Mosley in the ring! I feel bad for Cotto cause Marg took his soul! Hate on haters but he is the best" and so on. They dont have to just say "He cant be beaten" but it is implied. I'm a marg fan and a realist, every boxer has a chance of losing, and i think mosely may have a better chance than cotto, because experience may be key here. However i don't think he will beat margarito. I think before and after fights you get a higher influx of shit talking fanboys that want to hype thier dude and start shit with fans of other fighters, its just the nature of the beast. You can't base margaritos ratings on nuthuggers and fanboys, I don't think the Average intellegent boxing watcher overrates Tony here, they look at the fight objectively, IE I want Tony to win and i'm a fan and i think he's a favorite, however if Mosely Executes strategy A he could defeat Margarito.

When have Margarito fans said that? Find me a thread where more then one Margarito fan will even admit that Marg even has a chance of losing and we can talk. It's just like the people on here who only follow Pacman fights. They think he is God and cant be stopped. Most posts are something like "Nobody can touch the Mulleted madness of the Tornado!!! He is the greatest and most feared fighter in the world! He would KO FLoyd! He will kill Mosley in the ring! I feel bad for Cotto cause Marg took his soul! Hate on haters but he is the best" and so on. They dont have to just say "He cant be beaten" but it is implied.

http://images.musicclub.it/foto/iv/big/Ivan_Drago.tif.big.jpg "He is not Human, He is like iron"

No, but 99.9% of boxers dont have fans saying that they cannot be beaten when they already have been. When have Margarito fans said that?