The championship became vacant when reigning champ Floyd Mayweather Jr. retired and relinquished his belt in writing.
When the fight was made, Margarito was rated No. 1 and Mosley No. 3, which would seem to be at least a possible match up for THE RING championship.
However, it wasn’t that simple. Mosley had lost to No. 2-rated Miguel Cotto. And what if Paul Williams decided to drop back down to 147 pounds? Where would he fit in?
So Nigel Collins, the editor of THE RING magazine, sought input from his worldwide Ratings Advisory Panel and 25 members provided input. Roughly 55 percent indicated they didn’t want Margarito-Mosley to be for the world championship.
http://www.thering-online.com/blog/164/margaritomosley_isnt_quite_the_right_matchup_to_be_for_the_ring_belt/
it should have been.fact is, as long that it's between the one and the two or the three, it should be for the ring.the ring has too many vacants to begin with.the more ring champions we have the better it is for the sport.
I'm curious to the reason why 45% said yes. To me it's clearly a no because Cotto already beat Mosley.
But if that's the case, then Margarito already beat Cotto.
The only thing stopping this from being for The Ring belt is the possibility of Paul Williams coming back down to welterweight IMO.
TBH, i don't see how Mosley is even ranked 3 when he lost his last WW fight, won a LMW fight where thus Clottey has a belt now, that spot is Clotteys not Mosleys.
Thats a great decision. Very impressed with the Ring for sitting down and making the right choice.
And, this puts to bed some thoughts that Golden Boy has inappropriate influence on the magazine.
I have to admit there couldve been a more interesting fight then to pick mosley if you had the choice would you leave the fight like it is or who would you choose to fight margarito?
wasnt Margarito suppose to unify with Clottey in Nov? next best option was Mosley nothing after him.
I have to admit there couldve been a more interesting fight then to pick mosley if you had the choice would you leave the fight like it is or who would you choose to fight margarito?