Is Mayweather Jr one of the best ever boxers?

dont know? maybe he is...

Top 25 because of his skill & Talent. He has accomplished a good deal, but compared to some other champions in history that is almost mediocre.

Yes, definitely. He will be remembered as a boxer with superb skills but not as a warrior.

In the sense of talent.. yes, Floyd is among the best.. But in terms of achievment... NOPE...

Mayweather is not one of the best boxers he is the BEST. his record speaks for itself. 6 world titles in 5 different weight classes. he is the best ever.

Chop Chop........ corley you can actually argue is better than anyone floyd fought at 140 and 147. i just don't know how to judge zab...... great skills and talent BUT......

sharmba mitchell was the best 140 guy out there...... Chop Chop........

sharmba mitchell was the best 140 guy out there...... He comes under "The rest of 'em" :)

Yes he did! Gatti>Cotto>Hatton>Tszyu>Judah>The rest of 'em :) sharmba mitchell was the best 140 guy out there......

bullshit! he didn't fight the best 140-lbers at junior welterweight as well. :) Yes he did! Gatti>Cotto>Hatton>Tszyu>Judah>The rest of 'em :)

Nope he duck the real Welterweight threats. bullshit! he didn't fight the best 140-lbers at junior welterweight as well. :)

Man Floyd is defintely a top 50 boxer ever in my opinion but if he was to comeback and win the fights we wanna see him in then, he could go as high as top 20 maybe 10 Thats the thing about Mayweather. He still has time to raise his status on the ATG list. I hope he comes back, and does.

Man Floyd is defintely a top 50 boxer ever in my opinion but if he was to comeback and win the fights we wanna see him in then, he could go as high as top 20 maybe 10

He'd get Judahed by Tszyu.:D the truth.

He'd get Tua'ed by Lennox? tua was not 100% for the lewis fight. tua was robbed!!!!!

Top 50 is fair for him.

Arron would get hmmmm ....get some crack? Or get Bobby Joe Younged by Mayweather? :lol1:

top 50............ Agreed. He is in the top fifty. The funny thing about him is he never really dominated one division for any length of time so I can't say he is one of the best in 130, 140 etc etc. He was never in any division long enough to show true dominance. Anyway, do you mean (thread starter) one of the best, as in top ten, or just one of the best in general ie. top 50/100?

he'd get meldricked by julio...... he'd get arguelloed by aaron...... He'd get Judahed by Tszyu.:D

he'd get meldricked by julio...... he'd get arguelloed by aaron...... He'd get Tua'ed by Lennox?