you guys are overlooking Glen Johnson's counter right hand
he was able to nail Dawson with it another Southpaw and thoughout Calzaghe career he has been open to right hands and he has always had trouble against rough you up type guys like Reid,Bika,that IMO is Glen Johnson
this is why i think the fight would be closer than first impressions would lead you to believe
Joe Calzaghe by No Contest. Fight never happens as pulls out repeatedly with hand and wrist injuries.
After pulling out, Calzaghe said he'd still be ready for Johnson when he was healed.
Johnson was the one who said he didnt want the fight anymore.
Before you cry, im not saying Johnson ducked him cos he went on to make more fighting Tarver.
Calzaghe wins by decision, Johnson makes him work though
Who wins and how
Joe has lost some of his power and Johnson has a great chin, Johnson can bang and has good stamina, but the way to beat Johnson is to throw a lot of punches as it tends to neutralize him and Calzaghe throws a lot of punches. It would be a close one i would favor Joe but would never right johnson off.