Jose Luis Castillo an ATG?

58 votes said No he isn't an ATG

he didn't beat oscar. the commentators are a bunch of idiots that don't know boxing and they started all this propaganda against mayweather by doing a horrible job of commentating that night. the fight was mayweathers and all 3 judges thought the same. They all hate floyd so i wasn't surprised the worst is Emmanuel Steward

Though he beat Mayweather's ass I would say no. He will always be one of those fan favorites though!! he didn't beat oscar. the commentators are a bunch of idiots that don't know boxing and they started all this propaganda against mayweather by doing a horrible job of commentating that night. the fight was mayweathers and all 3 judges thought the same.

He is a Hall of Famer, but not an all time great.

No, A Mexican Atg ? Maybe yeah he is a hall of famer.. Great Warrior but not an ATG

No, A Mexican Atg ? Maybe

Hall of Fame, yes.ATG ,no cuz he lacked notable opposition besides Floyd and Corrales but certainly a hell of a fighter for his era.

who knows .... anyway at least the new one is a better one..

the ugly whale hoe? i think he lied to us yeah.

I'm gonna have to say no on this one!

Who is your avatar because the other female was supposed to be your wife or girl some shit like that the ugly whale hoe?

nope.... ^^^^ nice av...in fact BEAUTIFUL AV

Absolutely not

Because they fought each other. How they did against Floyd doesn't matter because they both lost. One guys Daddy stopped it, and the other used low blows, holding and hitting, and ineffective aggression to make some think he won...even though he lost by 4points on 2 cards and 5 on the other. Who is your avatar because the other female was supposed to be your wife or girl some shit like that

at 135 he had some very memorable fights but I dont think he is ATG

Not an ATG but he was a very good fighter in his prime.

I don't think i have seen any margarito nuthuggers in this thread yet.

K.O's Don't label you glass chinnded Knockdowns do, Castillo knocked him down twice before chico won and Mayweather knocked chico down 5 times. bump boofy the... (damn i can't think of a parody for buffy the body) whered did you go. you never answered. WAR GUZMAN!!

Chico never had a glass chin. He has been hit by the best and stopped how many times? Castillo has been stopped how many times? When Castillo tko'd him, Castillo couldn't even make weight, and was bigger than Chico. When comaring these guys style wise and their careers, the are very similiar in some ways. K.O's Don't label you glass chinnded Knockdowns do, Castillo knocked him down twice before chico won and Mayweather knocked chico down 5 times.

Left hook tua has spoilt me, I was expecting facts on the first page, such as records when fought etc. I don't have time for all that shit, your a boxing fan if you watch Castillo then you post in this thread.:boxing: