Prime For Prime Who Would Of Took David Tua Oliver Mcall?

height - mccall reach - mccall handspeed - tua speed - even footwork - mccall power - tua stamina - tua chin - even heart -tua durability - even

It could have been a hell of a fight. I think Tua would have had McCall thinking about a big left hook for a couple of rounds. Tua by SD......

Tua quits on the stool :D i knew i should have voted "flawless"......... :D

Both can punch tua being the harder puncher,both cast iron chins maybe mcall edging it in chin deparment? Great Match up Discuss! poll cotto man.

tua by decision. i don't see either getting koed but if one gets tkoed it'd be mccall. i've seen tua go through some real wars with guys that can punch and also have iron chins. gotta go with him. btw tua is not as slow as some think. fat tua is what is fresh in people's minds but tua actually has some handspeed. he's slow of foot though his handspeed and upper body movement was good when in his prime and at the correct weight of about 215 lbs.

Tua by decision IMO.

At his best I think McCall would decision Tua. He's quicker and has advantages wit height and reach that could cause Tua problems. a younger smaller tua was actually quicker than mcall and much more explosive. Tua had his biggest problems with taller jabbers and mcall never had a good jab. I think tua would have won by ud

eh........Tua by decision probably.

At his best I think McCall would decision Tua. He's quicker and has advantages wit height and reach that could cause Tua problems.

some1 damn reply!