Calzaghe vs Maywheather

RJJ started at jr. mw and went all the way to HW. roy jones is a beast its definatley harder to make those moves in the higher divisions. I guess none of the calzaghe fans wanted to come out and rep there boy. they'd rather thinks he's a legend and then try to compare his career to people who haven't been around long enough to establish a legacy. like pavlik taylor ect. im glad everybody respects what maywheathers done. it might be a while before we get another mayweather. it just sucks that it seems he has more to offer us as fans. calzaghe has a long way to go before he can be mentioned as a top 50 all time fighter. it sucks if its really frenk warrens fault for not exposing him to any real challenges

Well its a total no contest for me. No frank warren fighter will ever have a decent resume, they spend too much time fighting nobodies for no money. It baffles me why people sign contracts with that arsehole, if he sucks up any of our olympians i will cry

to be fare its a lot harder for a person to win 5 division titles if you start at supermiddlewieght. how many title defenses has mayweather had over his career and all the real champions he's faced his career is definatley superior in shorter time. RJJ started at jr. mw and went all the way to HW.

Mayweather is P4P better then Cazaghe and has a better resume. Simple question has a simple answer really so what's the motive of this thread/poll?

Mayweather is the better fighter and has the better resume, but he does need to fight a better opponent at 147. At 130 and 135 though he was a monster

to be fare its a lot harder for a person to win 5 division titles if you start at supermiddlewieght. how many title defenses has mayweather had over his career and all the real champions he's faced his career is definatley superior in shorter time.

while calzaghe continues to go back and forth on whether or not this his last fight the question I have to ask is considering he and maywheather both stay retired and remain undefeated yet leave with a huge feeling that they were leaving unfinished business and possibly running from an opponent or two. who leaves the bigger legacy and who leaves the most on the table? ten years from now will either be in your top 50 fighters and who would either be ranked in your top ten? pbf is a 5 division belt holder. let's see calzaghe do that then we'll talk.

Calzaghe may be 45-0 but 35 of those wins were bums. Now calzaghe is looking to enhance is record with big pay days against old fighters with big names. true maywheather has faught far fewer bums

i feel maywheather leaves more opportunity and ability behind. he was probably ducking more people but even with all that he still achieved way more in a shorter career than calzaghe. calzaghe didn't fight a lot of top level opponents until recently. but if he beat jones and pavlik convincingly and then beat hopkins convincingly in a rematch it would be real hard for me to say whose career was better but I would have to feel calzaghe finished way stronger and left no stone unturned but that probably won't happen Calzaghe may be 45-0 but 35 of those wins were bums. Now calzaghe is looking to enhance is record with big pay days against old fighters with big names.

i feel maywheather leaves more opportunity and ability behind. he was probably ducking more people but even with all that he still achieved way more in a shorter career than calzaghe. calzaghe didn't fight a lot of top level opponents until recently. but if he beat jones and pavlik convincingly and then beat hopkins convincingly in a rematch it would be real hard for me to say whose career was better but I would have to feel calzaghe finished way stronger and left no stone unturned but that probably won't happen

Mayweather leaves more behind than Joe. He was the P4P #1 on both record and ability IMO.