Who wins Margarito or Shane?

While i dont think shane would be stopped, i will come back to this thread when he fights mayorga, because that will seriously give us a little indication on how shane would do in a FIGHT at this point in his career. you know? Dude honestly Shane if he fought the right fight has the tools even at 35 to beat margarito. He still has good foot movement and a hard hook to the body which he can double up to the body and the head. he puncehs from many differnt angles and like I read in an earlier post has the fight experience to know when to clinch. Clinching could have helpd Cotto to outlast Margarito but that is neither here no there. Mosely would give Margarito a hell of a fight and I wuld pay to watch it. I don't know if I would pay to see Paul "The Freak" Williams fight Margarito or Clottey or wanna watch Zab quit on his stool for that matter. Cotto Margarito rematch will be pointless unless Cotto has proper time to heal from the last fight and a tune up match or two prior to taking on Margarito again. Money May aint coming out of retirement to fight Margarito and Oscar rather fight Manny then Margarito anyway. Point being said Mosely vs Margarito would be entertaining and worth paying to watch. i also think it would be very competitive and like I have stated before Shane has the ability to chaqnge his style mid fight which can confuse some. So if Shanes plan is not Mayorga and staying at 154 then maybe he comes down to Welter Weight or maybe margarito goes up to 154 to fight Shane?

Margarito wins this against the past his prime Mosley. too much workrate by margarito for mosley to be able to handle it. a mosley of a couple years ago would have been a very intersting fight

This past his prime Shane gets beaten. I agree with Temoc...Shane is not in his prime anymore. Why give the Marg haters more to talk about?

I think Shane got pull it out. It would be difficult however, Shane has a couple more fight left in hime. Past prime or not, Shane is still an elite fighter and probably the most naturally gifted fighter Margarito would have faced in he's career. Is anyone else bugged off the face that Shane is the only Household name left in the WW division? With Mayweather gone, Shane Mosely will be the only active fighter that your grandmother's heard off. Come to think about Shane is probably the only fighter that deliver these title holders the possiblity of a PPV fight, outside of a Cotto/Margarito rematch. Hell I'd outright favor Shane over Clotty and Berto if he were to fight them.

I think Shane isn't hungry anymore against Cotto he was talking like "this kind of fighter I fought so often, it's always the same" "I know all he can do, he won't stand a chance" "ah how training is going? ah I'm training my son for the last weeks"

Good points guys.

Yeah, that's why I think Shane can do well if he's as game as he was last November. While i dont think shane would be stopped, i will come back to this thread when he fights mayorga, because that will seriously give us a little indication on how shane would do in a FIGHT at this point in his career. you know?

This past his prime Shane gets beaten. Yup Yup Yup

He can also clinch, something Cotto failed to do, he's more battle tested Yeah, that's why I think Shane can do well if he's as game as he was last November.

At this point, Margarito by decision. I don't think he'd knock Mosley out and I think Mosley would be capable of making the fight competitive all the way.

At this point in his career I don't think Shane can dig deep enough anymore, I don't think he can win this one because he has slowed down quite a bit and a long powerful fighter would really cause him problems.

I dont ever wanna see this fight because it would basically be meaningless, but the shane mosley we know now has been in with some pretty big guys before and struggled, he would have to outwork margarito somehow, i dont know, at this point i really dont know. id have a better grasp of what hed do after the mayorga fight happens because right now i dont think shane really can keep his workrate up in the latter half of fights, and hes always struggled against bigger guys. He can also clinch, something Cotto failed to do, he's more battle tested

This past his prime Shane gets beaten.

Margarito. Shane got a little bit beat up by Cotto, but was able to survive it and come back quite strongly. He wouldn't be able to do that against Marg. it would probably look pretty similar to Marg - Cotto.

Style's really do make fights and Shane would be a hard task for Tony, with that said though, this would be a barn burner, better then both the Mosley V Cotto and the Margarito V Cotto fight! Ill take Tony by UD, he's got an iron chin with a machine workrate.

I dont ever wanna see this fight because it would basically be meaningless, but the shane mosley we know now has been in with some pretty big guys before and struggled, he would have to outwork margarito somehow, i dont know, at this point i really dont know. id have a better grasp of what hed do after the mayorga fight happens because right now i dont think shane really can keep his workrate up in the latter half of fights, and hes always struggled against bigger guys.