Ring P4P vs Boxing Scene P4P!

what happened to the thread where the OP (left hook tua i think) was gathering everyone's p4p lists to make one big defining boxingscene p4p top 10???

Why are we still debating Pac's position anyway ?

Pacman is number 1.

Wow, only Margarito and Pacquiao.

Do it man, that sounds cool, I'll post mine. You're idea, your a smart dude, but you got it from my idea, you biter! J/k. I wanna see how it plays out. okay. i'll do it.

just have everyone list their top 10. for every #10 vote give that boxer 1 point. 2 points for #9. 3 points for #8. all they way up to 10 points for #1. it'll be more accurate. it's a lot of hard work though. i'd do it if you want but i don't want to do one right now since you have your poll going. Do it man, that sounds cool, I'll post mine. You're idea, your a smart dude, but you got it from my idea, you biter! J/k. I wanna see how it plays out.

I'm too drunk to figure out what you want me to do.... sounds cool though further explanation please... just have everyone list their top 10. for every #10 vote give that boxer 1 point. 2 points for #9. 3 points for #8. all they way up to 10 points for #1. it'll be more accurate. it's a lot of hard work though. i'd do it if you want but i don't want to do one right now since you have your poll going.

Had to get it started, couldn't resist. Come on, he's coming off a great win. 1 win doesnt get u #1p4p. If he had beaten Paul Williams you got yourself a strong case. But as it stands he has 1 great win against 1 great fighter and not much else. He's 1 out of 3 against the biggest names on his resume

just giving you a hard time. i feel you. you know he's probably not gonna win the poll but you want him to have as much votes as possible. i feel you. you know what you should do? it'll get you a lot of replies and a gang of points. have people list their top 10 p4p. names only no bullshit arguing or explanation. and it has to be 10 guys. give 1 point for #10 and 10 points for #1. then you can add it up. I'm too drunk to figure out what you want me to do.... sounds cool though further explanation please...

Id say Pacquiao

Had to get it started, couldn't resist. Come on, he's coming off a great win. just giving you a hard time. i feel you. you know he's probably not gonna win the poll but you want him to have as much votes as possible. i feel you. you know what you should do? it'll get you a lot of replies and a gang of points. have people list their top 10 p4p. names only no bullshit arguing or explanation. and it has to be 10 guys. give 1 point for #10 and 10 points for #1. then you can add it up.

how could you vote for marg as #1 puas? :nonono: Had to get it started, couldn't resist. Come on, he's coming off a great win.

Below is the Ring Magazine top 10 P4P. Of the listed fighters, vote for who you think deserves the top spot, the number 1 ranking. This should give us a picture of how Boxing Scene fans, REAL fans, view the P4P rankings. http://img376.imageshack.us/img376/3688/p4p28jul08qv1.jpg how could you vote for marg as #1 puas? :nonono: