Here's mine
1) Margarito (beat the man)
2) Paul Williams (beat Margarito, but it was controversial. has since lost, though he avenged that lost with 1 rd blowout)
3) Shane Mosley (lost to cotto, but it was close enough that he reserved his place at the top. cotto gets sent below him for losing by ko)
4) Clottey (was dominant against margarito before breaking hand. hasn't lost since. can further elevate status by beating judah)
5) Collazo (controversial lost to Hatton that most press had him winning. Broke hand against Mosley in 2nd but held his own and hung in for 12 rounds. Won comeback fight convincingly and is being blatantly ducked by Berto, the "WBC champ")
6) Cotto (has to reestablish position at top after tko loss. still is likely the #2 welter but needs to rack up some more W's)
7) Judah (can elevate himself with win over clottey)
8) Berto (needs to fight someone with a pulse. preferably a professional boxer and not a cab driver, x-cop, bouncer, or construction worker)
9) Cintron (the hardest puncher in the division now will be sympathized with more. he will ko many despite not being able to phase the terminator!)
10) Mike Jones (could have said Quintana, but I prefer to go with Philly's unbeaten prospect. when will he step up his game?!?
Your thoughts on my rankings.... your rankings?!?
1. Margarito - (WBA) beat the #1 guy
2. Williams - (WBO) beat Margarito
3. Cotto - just lost #1 spot
4. Mosley - close loss to Cotto
5. Clottey - soon to be IBF champ, tough loss to Tony
6. Cintron - lost his belt to Margarito
7. Quintana - beat Williams for a belt, lost remat
8. Berto - (WBC) got a belt but still untested
9. Collazo - done nothn significant lately
10. Judah - ex champ ain't won a big fight since 2005
i say....as of right now
1. Paul Williams
2. Antonio Margarito
(those two can be switched around due to Margaritos win over Cotto but Williams did beat Margarito so i dont feel right rating him lower than Margarito.)
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Shane Mosley
5. Joshua Clottey
6. Carlos Quintana (does hold a win over Paul Williams)
7. Zab Judah
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Andre Berto
10. Luis Collazo
Your making fun of Berto's opposition, but you rank Mike Jones. Mike Jones comp is 10x worse than Berto's.
This is defintely a better list, How can you someone rank Margarito over williams at 147 when he lost to williams already?
1. Paul Williams- He beat the man(Margarito) who beat the man (Cotto).
2. Margarito
3. Cotto
4. Clottey
5. Mosley
Good List - Margo and Williams need to fight next before one of them exists to 154.
i say....as of right now
1. Paul Williams
2. Antonio Margarito
(those two can be switched around due to Margaritos win over Cotto but Williams did beat Margarito so i dont feel right rating him lower than Margarito.)
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Shane Mosley
5. Joshua Clottey
6. Carlos Quintana (does hold a win over Paul Williams)
7. Zab Judah
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Andre Berto
10. Luis Collazo
Your making fun of Berto's opposition, but you rank Mike Jones. Mike Jones comp is 10x worse than Berto's.
thats not a bad list. i put mike jones to mix it up. quintanas got ktfo by two of the top guys. i might have put him in at 10 but i wanted to mix it up. berto's opposition is still horrendous and he is ducking luis! collazo is underestimated- he's slick and can bang... thats why berto wants 2 pound. i hope lou gets his shot.
ok, fair enough... i like my list. whats your list brother?!?
i say....as of right now
1. Paul Williams
2. Antonio Margarito
(those two can be switched around due to Margaritos win over Cotto but Williams did beat Margarito so i dont feel right rating him lower than Margarito.)
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Shane Mosley
5. Joshua Clottey
6. Carlos Quintana (does hold a win over Paul Williams)
7. Zab Judah
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Andre Berto
10. Luis Collazo
Your making fun of Berto's opposition, but you rank Mike Jones. Mike Jones comp is 10x worse than Berto's.
Margarito's loss to Williams was controversial? Williams clearly won that fight bro.
Collazo and Mosley above Cotto? What has Mosley been doing at 147 besides losing to Cotto? Collazo beat a bum, lost to Hatton, beat a bum, got schooled by Mosley.
Terrible list in my opinion.
ok, fair enough... i like my list. whats your list brother?!?
Margarito's loss to Williams was controversial? Williams clearly won that fight bro.
Collazo and Mosley above Cotto? What has Mosley been doing at 147 besides losing to Cotto? Collazo beat a bum, lost to Hatton, beat a bum, got schooled by Mosley.
Terrible list in my opinion.
edit...just seen Collazo in your sig. No wonder. Won his comeback fight? What was his opponent record? 1-10?
Personally, at this stage even though he's green.........I think Andre Berto is a better fighter than Collazo and should be rated higher than him.
Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!
Looks good to me.
Except I'm not too sure about Collazo being that high.
Plus isn't he at 154 now?
Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!