Are These Fighters all time greats?

my definition of all time great is if a person can argue whether he is the best ever in that division. doesn't have to be the best of that division but if you can argue that he was then he's an all time great. so definitely no.

no . .

None of them is a great, but... Castillo has victories over Johnston, Casamayor, Corrales and gave Mayweather his toughest fight. That is a great record at 135 and is going to look impressive even in a few years. Forrest has two victories over Mosley. Gatti and Vargas great? please...

Fernando Vargas,Vernon Forrest,Arturo Gatti,Jose Luis Castillo? Wat ya think None of them are.

no........... HOf maybe

Fernando Vargas,Vernon Forrest,Arturo Gatti,Jose Luis Castillo? Wat ya think none of them.. IMO

Why didnt you put Emmanuel Augustus Burton in this thread? He's more deserving to be an all time great than Vargas

none of the above

Nah. Theres been some glitches lately, but I'm usually able to post more or less pain-free. Whats your user name over there? pm coming.

Does it take you forever to post on that site? It takes me about 5 min. from the time I hit reply til the time I can actually post something. Nah. Theres been some glitches lately, but I'm usually able to post more or less pain-free. Whats your user name over there?

I'm working on expanding my influence. :boxing: Does it take you forever to post on that site? It takes me about 5 min. from the time I hit reply til the time I can actually post something.

39 and 0 39 have tried and 39 have failed Technically, 38 have tried and failed. But otherwise, yep.....

not a one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm working on expanding my influence. :boxing:

Nope. Not a one. sherdog get boring?

Nope. Not a one.

JCL was a great fighter he might make it into the Hall of Fame. Gatti will make it into the Hall of Fame but not because of his achievments.

39 and 0 39 have tried and 39 have failed I know right? I scored the first fight a draw at MOST..Castillo didnt do enough to get a win, and got embarassed in the rematch

How do you more points committed to bets than what you currently have? by the time half of those fights come along, I will have the points,silly

Jose Luis Castillo and Vargas where involved in some of the greatest fights and had lots of heart, so I dunno what you would want to say. Castillo beat Mayweather once.