Does Zab Judah deserve a rematch with Cotto?

Zab doesn't even deserve the title shot he's getting, how the fukk could he possibly deserve a rematch with Cotto? When's the last time Zab beat a top 20 fighter?

I've heard a few people arguing this point. How does the forum feel? nope. it wasn't like their fight was a close split decision. if judah wants a rematch, he should work his way back up the welterweight ladder but I doubt he is capable(mentally) of doing that.

I don't usually come to the defense of Zab Judah, but I wouldn't describe Cory Spinks as a completely unknown person. again sorry, i meant in the first. The argument was that if it wasn't for the low-blow, Zab would've koed cotto in the first.

umm he stopped 3 people at welterweight (technically 4 cause that no contest against ruben galvan was bullshit) and one of the was cory spinks for all the belts!!! i think he was someone! my apologies, i meant in the first round, not overall.

Man, you are ignorant as hell kid. Judah has only koed one person in 147 and it was a completely unknown person and you think he was going to ko Cotto that has only been down once in his entire career in one round? I don't usually come to the defense of Zab Judah, but I wouldn't describe Cory Spinks as a completely unknown person.

Watch the fight before you say that. Zab won that fight by a clear 4 rounds. true. a horrible decision, but judah did have a few awful rounds. jesus.

Watch the fight before you say that. Zab won that fight by a clear 4 rounds. how come no one else has said that fight was a robbery but you.

Man, you are ignorant as hell kid. Judah has only koed one person in 147 and it was a completely unknown person and you think he was going to ko Cotto that has only been down once in his entire career in one round? umm he stopped 3 people at welterweight (technically 4 cause that no contest against ruben galvan was bullshit) and one of the was cory spinks for all the belts!!! i think he was someone!

what cost judah the fight was his weak mentality when he gets pressured. he just can't handle pressure. he couldn't handle powerless Baldomirs pressure. :lol1: well said. it pisses me off when people say that the only reason why he lost was because of a low-blow.

Yes of course they will be. The only fair and part fo the fight when cotto wasn't cheating. Wsa the first round and had the low blow number 1 not landed zab would have ko'd him in one. Cotto was on his last legs then when in trouble in the third round he does it agaain like a little bitch. That with the punches to the back, back of head and constant headbutts was what cost Zab the fight. Man, you are ignorant as hell kid. Judah has only koed one person in 147 and it was a completely unknown person and you think he was going to ko Cotto that has only been down once in his entire career in one round?

That didn't change the fight or have any effect at all on the fight. what cost judah the fight was his weak mentality when he gets pressured. he just can't handle pressure. he couldn't handle powerless Baldomirs pressure. :lol1:

Ummmm.... Hmmm maybe take out the low blows... Then ya would have Cotto rattled 2-3 times... But ya never know how much the low blows really took out of Judah... maybe they didnt take that much.

he does in a way, he fouhg tvery i thought he had a chance before the low blows; he showed some heart; but in another way he doesn't he has not had a good solid win against a good quality opp. to deserve another title shot

at 3:36 of the video is when judah connects with the left that stuns cotto. then judah starts throwing his flurries and cotto is dodging and moving from judah's attack and cotto is throwing punches back. then cotto is perfectly fine throwing back punches until the low blow. no excuses for the low blow take it how you want but he was not hurt, he was wobbled or stunned but gained his composure and continued fighting. in that video its clear that he didnt lowblow to stop from gettin ko'd cuz he was hurt. theres no convincing the detractors.judah's headbutts didn't mean shit.

Yes of course they will be. The only fair and part fo the fight when cotto wasn't cheating. Wsa the first round and had the low blow number 1 not landed zab would have ko'd him in one. Cotto was on his last legs then when in trouble in the third round he does it agaain like a little bitch. That with the punches to the back, back of head and constant headbutts was what cost Zab the fight. your moaning about low blows..... The real reason judah lost was because of his weak mentality when pressured.

it's funny how some people say that Zab only loss the fight 'cause of the low-blows. People who have been in the ring would tell you otherwise... If he wind against clottey(witch i highly doubt) Then he will have some argument over a rematch. But the truth is that Cotto would bust him up much worst than last time

i hope they fight again so the tits can shut up all ready.

I dont think so the first fight was good but it wasnt close enough to warrent a rematch

My question to the skeptics are, did Cotto's low blows cause Zab the fight? What does that say about Zab? Low blows happen, it's apart of boxing. Zab couldn't handle Cotto's pressure and couldn't see Cotto's punches coming. A rematch would mean an even worse beating as Cotto has gotten that much better since they've fought. Pointless rematch IMO

at 3:36 of the video is when judah connects with the left that stuns cotto. then judah starts throwing his flurries and cotto is dodging and moving from judah's attack and cotto is throwing punches back. then cotto is perfectly fine throwing back punches until the low blow. no excuses for the low blow take it how you want but he was not hurt, he was wobbled or stunned but gained his composure and continued fighting. in that video its clear that he didnt lowblow to stop from gettin ko'd cuz he was hurt.