Emmanuel Steward's Top 5 P4P

Yes he has. Not in my book. This is subjective, its about opinions. And in my opinion, Marquez has shown he's better than Pacquiao twice now.

At the end of the replay of the Pacquiao-Diaz fight , Emmanuel stated his Top 5 pound for pound. 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Miguel Cotto 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Kelly Pavlik Agree? Discuss. It's a pretty good list, but Calzaghe should be at #2 and Cotto at #3.

Cotto at number 2...... Just think, if Pacquiao loses to Hatton and Calzaghe retires after fighting Jones Jr, Cotto could be #1 p4p. Maybe then, Floyd will fight him.

I agree ........................

Close enough, Cotto definatly isn't 2 though 3 I can deal with but he hasn't beaten a top 10 p4p fighters yet. 1. Pacman 2. Calzaghe 3. Cotto/Marquez anything past that is subjective.

Good list Marquez might be a bit to high, but the rest is right on.

Top 5 P4p 1. Manny Pacquiao (would be MAYWEATHER) 2. Miguel Cotto 3. Juan Manuel Marquez 4. Kelly Pavlik 5. 5. Will be the winner of Roy Jones Jr (I think he deserves it once he puts joe on his ass) VS Calzaghe. If the winner of that fight takes on Pavlik I would have them ranked at 2. Cotto moving to 3 and Marguez moving to 4 and the loser of Pavlik Vs winner of Jones vs Calzaghe would be number 5. I probably dont make any sense and I bet NO ONE agrees with me. lol o well just the way I see it. Of course thats my rating if Calzaghe still decides to fight once he looses to Jones. If Mayweather decides to come back that would throw it all off too....because Cotto would be OFF the map!

That's a good list.

At the end of the replay of the Pacquiao-Diaz fight , Emmanuel stated his Top 5 pound for pound. 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Miguel Cotto 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Kelly Pavlik Agree? Discuss. Not too far away from mine.

Cotto #2? :lol1:

At the end of the replay of the Pacquiao-Diaz fight , Emmanuel stated his Top 5 pound for pound. 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Miguel Cotto 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Kelly Pavlik Agree? Discuss. My list is always changing, but here is mine. 1. Pac 2. Cal 3. vasquez 4. JMM 5 Cotto 6. Raf Marquez 7. Pavlik 8. Hopkins 9. Mijares 10. campbell

Doesnt p4p include personal preference? At least thats what my interpretation of the word pound for pound means. Who YOU think is the best out there by the pound. For instance, if someone thinks Calzhaghe has been unimpressive then I see no reason they cannot lower him on their p4p ratings. You guys are trying to work the triangles and all these other factors when p4p lists involve opinion for a lot of it.

how did cotto get above calzaghe for beating gomez? ha ha ha joe beat manfredo (his contender) joe should be above cotto. zab and old mosley is not as good as eubank and old hopkins. joe has beat more top 10 guys than cotto.

1. Pacquiao 2. Calzaghe 3. Cotto 4. JMM 5. Bhop

Not a bad list at all. JMM has to be that high. He is fucking awesome. Haha so I guess you missed Cotto's rating? Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

lol'ing with anyone lol'ing @ Cotto being above Marquez. Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

Not a bad list at all. JMM has to be that high. He is fucking awesome.

I agree with Manny. IMO i see P4P as those who can perform great in more than 1 weight class. I don't see too much of that from JMM. I see Pac as top for sure. Cotto is a good two for the quality opposition. Pavilk is fine where he is at. Pavilk and Calzaghe are the best Between the weights of 160-175. For those saying Pac didn't beat JMM "in there book" well here:bottle: Cause JMM definitely didn't beat Pac. He got put on is ass 4 times in two fights by him and history will remember that. he may have won some rounds but he was more hurt from the two fights atleast to the point where he got knocked down FOUR times. ahhhh we can argue this until forever. LOL @ cintron being 6 or 7. Manny doesn't even like him. I doubt he'll be working with him in the future. and that's a shame. Steward gave him all the wrong advice in that fight. Many would have done a much better job managing him during the fight.

It's a good list but there's no way Cotto is number 2 P4P.

At the end of the replay of the Pacquiao-Diaz fight , Emmanuel stated his Top 5 pound for pound. 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Miguel Cotto 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Kelly Pavlik Agree? Discuss. how did cotto get above calzaghe for beating gomez?